Rated 4 out of 5 by Kalynn Decent Ingedients, Cats Love it
This food is a pate and smells pretty good as cat foods go. It's pretty thick, so I have been adding a little water to get it to an appropriate consistency. After feeding it 50/50 with a natural dry diet for about a week, here are my thoughts:
- My cats love this food. They love it more than any other food I've ever fed them including Fancy Feast. Both of them lick the bowls clean even my dry food addict.
- It has no fish. This is great for the contaminant issue but critical for us since one of the cats is allergic to fish.
- High protein, pretty good ingredients.
- No carageen.
The Not So Good
- Has pea flour. What does a cat need with legume flour? It's just a way to add cheap carbs while staying "grain free."
- Menadione Dimethylpyrimidinol Bisulfite- Since there is no fish in this food, I'm not sure why vitamin K supplementation is necessary.
Conclusion: For me, it's a winner so far because the cats will eat it, and while I wish some the ingredients were different, I'm generally happy with the quality.
March 17, 2014
Rated 4 out of 5 by Windsurfer Healthy Food my Cats really Like!
After searching & trying many brands of cat food to give my 4 cats (various ages) a healthier option without byproducts, etc., I am Very pleased with this food. Have been feeding it for almost a year and my kitties still Love it! : ) Their coats are shining and weights are perfect. Worth trying!!
March 5, 2014
Rated 3 out of 5 by Nuts4Cats Pros & Cons
I chose this particular line of the brand because of its superior ingredients and the fact that is doesn't have byproducts or carrageenan. My cat liked it, too. However, I have since discovered that it has 25% carbs on a dry matter basis, which is way too high. I try to keep it below 5%. So I will not be buying it again and cannot really recommend it.
September 15, 2014
Rated 3 out of 5 by Meh0 Not Appetizing
I bought this because my cat has IBS, but he won't touch the stuff and prefers to eat his other food (zd) which he still doesn't like either.
My other kitten tries to bury it like it's poo.
My 3rd cat is a porker and will eat it no problem.
December 11, 2014
Rated 5 out of 5 by capjoe Very nice Pate'
All four cats from 2years old to 16 love this nice consistency pate'. It smells like a human quality food and has nothing but premium ingredients. When all plates are clean, I'm a happy momma.
June 9, 2015
Rated 5 out of 5 by LoveCats99 High quality organic cat food!
My cat loves ByNature Organics cat food. And Chewy.com has a good selection, great prices and fast shipping.
June 14, 2014
Rated 3 out of 5 by 3catmom "New" By Nature canned cat food, "Olio" it's not!
I am not impressed with the new "by nature" chicken/chicken liver canned cat food. Only 2 of our 4 cats will eat it, and then only after we put primal freeze dried food on top of it. "Olio" it is not!!! A lady from by nature told me it is very similar to the "olio" brand they used to have. Not at all! I heard it is now made in a foreign country and not in the United States. This food is very light in color, has "gel" on top and in it. The smaller around cans are taller and it's hard to get the food out of the can because it is very thick, and you can't get it all out of the crease in the bottom sides of the can. Not sure if I will buy this again, I guess I will see if my cats will eat the remaining 22 cans.
July 14, 2015
Rated 3 out of 5 by SouthernCountiesRescue Some like it, some don't
I do rescue so have lots of cats with different backgrounds mostly use to eating junk food. Some of my cats will eat this and others really don't care for it.
I would give 4 stars based on ingredients but would give it 2 stars based on the number who want to eat it, so ended up with 3 stars.
September 18, 2015