Rated 5 out of 5 by PatterdaleMom Excellent
Long-lasting! They aren't odor-free, but they don't smell as strongly as some other bully sticks I've bought. My dogs LOVE them and the price is right. These are a nice diameter; not too thin like some other brands. I just ordered another pack. :)
January 15, 2014
Rated 4 out of 5 by pip728 Will purchase again!!
I recently discovered that my cocker loves bully sticks. This brand seems is economical and she really gnaws on them--doesn't chew them up inside of 5 minutes!! She immediately devoured a different organic brand stick. These are thicker but she doesn't get excited when I give one to her…and there are some she won't touch. Don't know if she is tired of them?! I have a bowl that holds the half-eaten ones. She regularly takes one out and does a little gnawing….Hope that's enough to keep her teeth clean. BTW I have not detected any odor.
January 31, 2015
Rated 3 out of 5 by cobu Mixed feelings
These seem high quality, they are thick and solid.
But I expected more from this product based on reviews.
First and foremost, these smell TERRIBLE! And while i can put up with the terrible rotten belly button smell for the sake of my dogs' enjoyment, only one of my two dogs SORT OF likes it SOMETIMES, and she's really not picky with treats, this one.
And the off putting smell wouldn't have bothered me as much had this product not been advertised as "low odor."
In conclusion: terrible smell, dogs don't love it, not worth it.
June 19, 2014
Rated 3 out of 5 by shopaholicamy these smell
I ordered a few of the bully sticks and these were the smelliest ones I have ever ordered. I couldn't wait until my dog got through these! I would pay more for ones that do not have the bad odor. It was so bad, I didn't want the dog to chew it inside the house!
January 16, 2015
Rated 5 out of 5 by Trecee25 My puppy loves it!
When my high-energy puppy has a bully stick, I don't have to worry about what she's doing for a whole hour. The barking stops; the running around the house stops; the destructive chewing stops; all attention is given to this bully stick. She loves it! Will definately recommend to anyone with a high-energy pup.
December 3, 2014
Rated 2 out of 5 by York2 Too hard for small dogs
Not enough scent to them to get my little dogs even interested in tackling them.
February 10, 2015
Rated 1 out of 5 by SeanCoal First bag was good, the current bully sticks are really dried and burnt
I got a smaller bag to try out after reading good reviews and overall happy with them except for two minor things, they're really smelly, but not a big issue just gave dog in "his" room and also wish they last more than 10min but that's true with other 6in bully sticks. I was happy enough to order the 50pc bag. Unfortunately, it was shipped in the same box as with the arm & hammer vacuum powder I also ordered. The small powder leaked from the seams of the box, so there was about 1/2 cup of powder in the box and the two food items smell really strong of the a&m powder even though both were wrapped in plastic. The powder seeped into the plastic bags. I unwrapped the bone I purchased, rinsed and dried off to give to my dog. My poor dog got diarrhea about an hour later. Good thing he has a strong stomach and had only a couple of episodes, then he was fine. I felt really bad and wasn't going to give him the bully sticks, so called Chewy and they were great in replacing with a new bag. (BTW, really should make sure cleaning products be put into a sealed plastic bag before shipping with food items.) I recd the new bag in 2 days, no problems there but this bag's bully sticks are really dark in color, they're dried and burnt out looking, and really lightweight and hollow. I think they're overly dried? It doesn't even smell anymore and I actually can handle them without gaging, I guess it's the only positive. I didn't want to deal with replacing them again, so been giving my dog these sticks, but they really don't last at all, maybe 5min tops. I can hear he "crunches" when eating them like potato chips. I wouldn't have ordered them if the first bag was like this current batch. Also, for the inconsistent quality, I won't be ordering them again. Too bad, since I like the price and at first I like the product.
July 7, 2014
Rated 3 out of 5 by JudyMC Not as big a hit as I thought it would be.
I have two dogs, a Vizsla and a Mini Schnauzer. The Vizsla had no problem chewing on this for less than an hour, devouring it, but my Mini Schnauzer was not enticed.
Bully's are expensive, so I would like for them to last more than 30 minutes. I can't afford to give my dogs a Bully so often.
Others may have a different experience with these, but I would probably not order again, because of the expense, and that it is not long lasting.
May 19, 2014