Customer Reviews

Rating: 4.1 of 5 stars 17 Reviews 17 Reviews 4.2 out of 5 Stars

88% Recommend

88% of reviewersrecommend this product

Rating: 4.1 of 5 stars 4.2 / 5

You've Already Reviewed This Item

Carefresh Premium Western Timothy Hay Rabbit Food

Carefresh Premium Western Timothy Hay Rabbit Food

  • Most Helpful Positive Review

    Read All 12 Positive Reviews

    My rabbit and I recommend this hay!

    By Mary on Aug 23, 2021

    I've used a different brand of hay for years, but recently I tried this brand. It smells noticeably stronger and fresher, and it is easy to grab handfuls out of the bag. My other brand was not so easy to do that. My rabbit likes it just fine, and the price is good, so I will continue to buy the Carefresh I've used a different brand of hay for years, but recently I tried this brand. It smells noticeably stronger and fresher, and it is easy to grab handfuls out of the bag. My other brand was not so easy to do that. My rabbit likes it just fine, and the price is good, so I will continue to buy the Carefresh. I only recently realized that timothy hay is intended for older rabbits, and alfalfa hay is intended for younger ones because of its high calcium levels. I'm now paying more attention to the composition of the pellets too and avoiding some of the less expensive pellets because they are made of wheat and alfalfa meal and other stuff that may not actually be as good as a simple timothy-based pellet. … more

    You liked it! Something went wrong. Please try again later. Report
  • Most Helpful Critical Review

    Read All 5 Critical Reviews

    EHHHHH!!! -

    By GPIGSROCK on Nov 8, 2021

    All hay batches differ!!! No matter the "brand"!!. This hay cutting was not as green and LOVELY as what I got from Kaytee in the past. HOWEVER!! GPIGS get most of their nutrition from feed and veggies. The hay is more for fiber and chewing anyhow!! It is just OKAY!!...

    You liked it! Something went wrong. Please try again later. Report

17 Reviews

Showing 1-10 of 17 Reviews

  • 3 out of 5 stars

    EHHHHH!!! -

    By on

    All hay batches differ!!! No matter the "brand"!!. This hay cutting was not as green and LOVELY as what I got from Kaytee in the past. HOWEVER!! GPIGS get most of their nutrition from feed and veggies. The hay is more for fiber and chewing anyhow!! It is just OKAY!!...

    You liked it! Something went wrong. Please try again later. Report
  • 5 out of 5 stars

    Happyhappy

    By on

    Me and my girl rabbit really love this. It has nice long pieces that all bunnies love. It took us a long time to find a really good hay and this is it.

    You liked it! Something went wrong. Please try again later. Report
  • 5 out of 5 stars

    My rabbit and I recommend this hay!

    By on

    I've used a different brand of hay for years, but recently I tried this brand. It smells noticeably stronger and fresher, and it is easy to grab handfuls out of the bag. My other brand was not so easy to do that. My rabbit likes it just fine, and the price is good, so I will continue to buy the Carefresh. I only recently realized that timothy hay is intended for older rabbits, and alfalfa hay is intended for younger ones because of its high calcium levels. I'm now paying more attention to the composition of the pellets too and avoiding some of the less expensive pellets because they are made of wheat and alfalfa meal and other stuff that may not actually be as good as a simple timothy-based I've used a different brand of hay for years, but recently I tried this brand. It smells noticeably stronger and fresher, and it is easy to grab handfuls out of the bag. My other brand was not so easy to do that. My rabbit likes it just fine, and the price is good, so I will continue to buy the Carefresh. I only recently realized that timothy hay is intended for older rabbits, and alfalfa hay is intended for younger ones because of its high calcium levels. I'm now paying more attention to the composition of the pellets too and avoiding some of the less expensive pellets because they are made of wheat and alfalfa meal and other stuff that may not actually be as good as a simple timothy-based pellet. … more

    You liked it! Something went wrong. Please try again later. Report
  • 5 out of 5 stars

    Bunny approved

    By on

    My minilop, Arizona, is obsessed with this hay! She chews and digs holes through the bag just to get some of this fresh hay. Arrived quickly and super green! Not much dust which makes it perfect! 10/10 recommend

    You liked it! Something went wrong. Please try again later. Report
  • 3 out of 5 stars

    Decent hay, not our favorite

    By on

    We tried this hay for the first time a few weeks ago. I hope it was a late cut of hay because it was very “sticky” with more stalks than grass. My guinea pigs don’t eat the stalks so it felt like a lot of waste.

    You liked it! Something went wrong. Please try again later. Report
  • 5 out of 5 stars

    We Absolutely Love This!

    By on

    When we got the hay in the mail it had such an amazing fresh Timothy hay smell. The hay wasn’t too hard or too soft it was just right. My bunnies did take a couple days to get use to the new hay but they have been loving it ever since. Also love how there’s more than one size! Also very affordable!

    You liked it! Something went wrong. Please try again later. Report
  • 3 out of 5 stars

    Bought for my guinea pigs

    By on

    I bought this as a change for my guinea pigs. Normally they eat Oxbow hay. Overall the hay is good, but it’s a lot more dusty than Oxbow and there were stones in the bag. I will not buy again because of this.

    You liked it! Something went wrong. Please try again later. Report
  • 4 out of 5 stars

    Need More Longer Strands

    By on

    The hay was good - smelled fresh, good amount of seed heads. Just wish they hadn’t chopped up so much of the hay into 3 to 4 inches! My guinea pigs need and prefer long strand hay. Also, there were a lot of hard pieces among the longer strands - need some more softer hay in there. Minimal dust was a plus.

    You liked it! Something went wrong. Please try again later. Report
  • 2 out of 5 stars

    Satisfactory product

    By on

    For this hay, it was my first time trying this brand. It did have alot of dust and very small miniscule pieces that just made a mess in the cage There was also alot of very sharp pieces as well. My 4 guinea pigs did like it but I only used this brand hay as a "treat". Then after they eat what they want out of it, I throw out the sharp edges pieces that they left behind because we don't need any eye hay poke emergencies. The other hay that I use for them to borrow in and also munch on is from Farmer Dave's Pet Supply. That in fact is the best hay that you will get your money's worth. Google it and check it out. I will try the Carefresh hay one more time and if it is not any better I will not buy For this hay, it was my first time trying this brand. It did have alot of dust and very small miniscule pieces that just made a mess in the cage There was also alot of very sharp pieces as well. My 4 guinea pigs did like it but I only used this brand hay as a "treat". Then after they eat what they want out of it, I throw out the sharp edges pieces that they left behind because we don't need any eye hay poke emergencies. The other hay that I use for them to borrow in and also munch on is from Farmer Dave's Pet Supply. That in fact is the best hay that you will get your money's worth. Google it and check it out. I will try the Carefresh hay one more time and if it is not any better I will not buy it anymore. SOOOO they have 1 more chance. … more

    You liked it! Something went wrong. Please try again later. Report
  • 5 out of 5 stars

    3 happy gerbils

    By on

    My little guys love this stuff! They may only get it once a week but they enjoy using it to build their beds

    You liked it! Something went wrong. Please try again later. Report