Cloud Star Wag More Bark Less Grain-Free Oven Baked with Peanut Butter & Apples Dog Treats

I just purchased these for my dog and as I was breaking them into pieces for him, I noticed that there were a bunch of bugs inside. Keep in mind the box was recently purchased and the expiration date was fine. So just a forewarning if you choose to buy these.

At first my dog dropped the treat on the floor and just looked at it. I thought she didn't like it but the second time I gave it to her she gobbled it right up. Now she loves them, Can't say she barks less but she diffidently wags more!

I prefer to buy my dogs' snacks in bulk to save money. We're on month 3 and I'm nowhere near halfway through this box. Very few of the treats I have seen are broken. My dogs love them!

I've bought this product before and the dogs like them along with their meals. Chewy had a large box of them on sale (19 pounds) - best buy ever - hope they do it again!

My dog is on a natural, low-inflammatory diet (primarily gluten-free and no artificial colors). She loves these and I am happy to be able to give them to her!

I have been buying these vegan adorable shaped treats for years I have 5 rescue dogs -my dogs love them and I like the ingredients and cute shape---BUT- DO NOT BUY THE 19 LBS box ---I bought it because of the sale price-I have 5 dogs and also go to the kill shelter to give hundreds of healthy treats to hundreds of dogs and I have very little money, but do buy it from my own money, because I love the dogs and my heart breaks for them-they go through so much already---ANYHOW--I bought this 19 LBS BOX for the first time ever and even though Chewy was great as always and refunded my money right away &told me to donate it to the shelter etc,I originally called about the box, because it arrived completely I have been buying these vegan adorable shaped treats for years I have 5 rescue dogs -my dogs love them and I like the ingredients and cute shape---BUT- DO NOT BUY THE 19 LBS box ---I bought it because of the sale price-I have 5 dogs and also go to the kill shelter to give hundreds of healthy treats to hundreds of dogs and I have very little money, but do buy it from my own money, because I love the dogs and my heart breaks for them-they go through so much already---ANYHOW--I bought this 19 LBS BOX for the first time ever and even though Chewy was great as always and refunded my money right away &told me to donate it to the shelter etc,I originally called about the box, because it arrived completely open unsealed untaped and open trash bag like ripped thick ,but totally open plastic bag--no expiration date on the actual box but a handwritten sticker with what looked like an old expiration date---I had not thrown it out- I was taking it to the shelter dogs-but even they do not deserve such unacceptable rotten nasty expired treats --yesterday I looked at the box & I already fed 2 thirds of it (hundreds of treats eaten already)and I could not believe my eyes -I am not petty or picky by any means -This was shocking to me-hundreds of black little flies and cob web strings & strings & rotten spiderweb like moldy strings and tons & tons of little bugs flying in the bag -this was on the lower level so I did not even notice that part at first -but I just bought this box just now- but fed so many dogs-I took pictures and not able to upload this from my digital camera here now-Trust me I have never seen such a rotten expired food item before-I feel bad for all the dogs that ate pounds and pounds of these before I was aware how bad the state of this box was-I am not exaggerating-I cannot believe Chewy would sell something like this-I know it was not intentional -but it got me worried for the dogs who ate these now-anyone thinking of buying this huge box for the full price of almost one hundred $$-make sure to call CHEWY BEFORE to find out if this is a new fresh box --I also bought the 19 lbs box of the same treats with Pumpkin flavor on sale-worried about that item just as much now-but I do absolutely love these treats in the small bag and will always buy those still-I love the vegan Cloudstar treats for my dogs usually-it now got me worried about 28 lb dry dog food bags I buy on sale ,too-are they expired also..sorry---I do love the idea of industrial size healthy treats for multiple dogs and shelters with hundreds of dogs-were huge amounts of treats are gone in minutes -because they all want one-I wish there were huge bags and boxes that are affordable and healthy- so multiple dogs and hundreds of shelter dogs can be happy with some good treat ,too-the 5 stars are for the fresh treat itself -but decomposing box no … more

Peanut butter and apple flavored treats are a hit with our dogs. We like giving them a treat that isn't always meat based. Though our dogs don't care about the shape of these treats, they are cute and our dogs enjoy eating them.

my lab loves these treats and they are a perfect size. He seems to really enjoys the peanut/apple favor.

3 stars because They came completely broken in the box but my dog doesn't care, he still thinks they're yummy lol even if theyre in a million pieces

I posted a review a couple weeks ago about the fact that bugs came out of these treats which is disgusting and I ended up having to throw them away and before that my dog wouldn’t eat them and my review was deleted which is very disappointing to see that as the only response