Rated 5 out of 5 by Bichon4 My 4 love these!
I have 4 small bichons. They absolutely love these. The treats are too hard to cut up, but even my finicky 12 lb bichon loves these. Takes her a while to eat these, but she loves them so much, it doesn't bother her. All 4 have had many many teeth pulled, That still doesn't stop them! They love cheese and love these!
October 20, 2016
Rated 5 out of 5 by Peties1mom Likes
He likes the taste because it is round enjoys playing with it first
October 16, 2016
Rated 5 out of 5 by Armicia Perfect!
These are awesome! My dogs are 50-60lbs and these are the perfect size imo. I can give them one a few times a day and they aren't so big that I'm afraid they'll gain weight, but they aren't so small that they just swallow them and then look at me like "where's the rest?". They are also the perfect size because they don't leave crumbs! They can chew a couple times and nothing falls out. I love that feature.
A few people posted that they smelled terrible. I thought they smelled delicious! And I hate the smell of Parmesan cheese, blech.
As other people mentioned, not all dogs like these. I have 2 that will eat just about anything and one weirdo dog that is very picky. Mr. picky will eat these but he acts like he's being punished. The other 2 gobble them up and will do anything I ask them to do if they think they are getting one. I'll try the other flavors and see if I can't find one Mr. picky can enjoy as well.
July 26, 2016
Rated 1 out of 5 by Stephanie this is not for small dogs
I am sure they are very tasty but unless you cut them up into very small pieces it is very hard for a dog who is small 15 to 25 pounds too true them they will break their teeth because the cookies are like rocks! It is also very hard for me to even cut them.
October 14, 2016
Rated 2 out of 5 by KodasMom Not The Usual Fromm Quality
These are "cookies" I regularly purchase for my dogs in all varieties. This particular couple of packages seemed to be over baked. The edge of each "cookie" was dark brown hinging on almost black. Even the thickness varied from normal to less than half! All the other flavors I purchased were Fromm's typical high quality! Normally I would have given 5 stars. This batch only deserved 2.
October 2, 2016
Rated 5 out of 5 by DMichi VERY hard, like a biscuit, but my dog loves<3
We're a fan of these, but it takes a while to get through them. I wouldn't consider them training treats, though, they're pretty big. More like a big reward, like for bringing a ball back or doing a good recall, since it takes a second to eat. My dog loves them. Wouldn't give them to a little dog since it's a hard crunch, like a cookie -- harder than a milkbone, for example. But my 44lb aussie likes them, just crunches it in his teeth and waits for more.
September 25, 2016
Rated 3 out of 5 by Becky20 Good ingredients.
Some other dog might like these. Mine just does not get excited about it. He ate the first one, but just walks away when I offer him one. I don't think he likes it being hard and evidently does not like the smell or taste.
September 29, 2016
Rated 5 out of 5 by Jake682 Love Fromm
We always prefer Fromm products for their quality ingredients. These crunchy treats are a favorite of my dogs. The treats don't smell much, but they must taste good!
September 28, 2016