My cats were not interested in the toys at all. and they love catnip.
These plushy toys are perfect! They crinkle, have catnip, are soft, and the cats carry them all over the house. We try to match the toys floating around the house with the current holidays so we just put away all the Halloween and pulled out Christmas (sorry Thanksgiving I found no toys lol) but these will be perfect for months because while I won't want Santa toys in January/February I'm ok with gloves and mittens mixed in with their usual toys that float around. Boxing up holiday toys and bringing them out again next year also brings back their excitement I think :)
I can't go wrong with catnip toys for my cat and these are adorable