Fromm Four-Star Nutritionals Grain-Free Lamb with Cranberry Recipe Dog Treats, 8-oz bag

My small dog can be a little finicky. And the biscuits I get for my golden doodle are too large. Sometimes I choose by asking myself: if it were for humans would I get it? Lamb and cranberry sounded good to me so I tried it and ....she loves it!

We are quickly becoming a Fromm family for our Pyr Pup Thor. He eats the Fromm Large Breed Puppy, and these treats were a real win. When he hears the jar rattle that these are stored in he sits down so fast for a treat his butt thumps on the floor!! My friend makes amazing homemade locally sourced dog treats that are our usual pup snacks and they are hard to beat but we'll definitely be re-buying these for a go-to purchased treat! FYI these treats are fairly large and firm crunchy snacks that worked fine for our boy (at 4 months he is 40lb so his Great Pyrenees puppy teeth are rather large) but they might be a bit big for a smaller breed.

I have 3 dogs. One of them will eat the pattern off her dish she loves to eat so much. These treats, however, just are not her thing. She wont eat them unless one of the other dogs goes for it. Dont count on these being loved by every dog.

My dogs LOVE these - and they are full of healthy ingredients. About 1/2 inch thick and not quite the size of a quarter in diameter. Crunchy, but not too hard for the oldster's teeth.

For the most part, these treats are great! My only issue is that the picture makes it looks like they're much smaller than they actually are, but they're a little too big for my 8 week old shepherd puppy to eat as treats when we train. However, they're good for a "super" treat, like when I come home and he's spent a while in his crate, so they still serve a purpose!!

So I have had dogs all my life, long before the pet companies started to mix in the vegies, fruits and real meat. I would customize their food bowls with the human food...always being told by the other half (not always the better) that you are going to spoil them and they wont eat their own food...long store short thanks for catching up, and producing a clean healthy treat for my dogs and their friends...ATS-Denver

I was looking for a healthy alternative to the typical biscuits you see at the store (milkbone, kirkland, etc.) and these fit the bill nicely. The only problem we had was that they were a little too hard for my dog's liking. He usually inhales any kind of treat, and while he did eat these eventually, he would only do so after sniffing it for a while and nudging it around with his nose. He definitely had an "I guess" attitude towards them, probably due to both the flavor and texture. We may have better luck with the other flavors.

My dog gets super-excited when I take out the package. However, once I give him the cookie it takes him a couple of tries to figure out how to bite into it since they are hard as a rock. Doesn't stop him though...

I am extremely pleased with the snacks and with chewy.com. my dogs love them and the wonderful convenient service I couldn't ask for anything more. I can't beat the price I can't beat the service and my dogs can't get enough of the treats and the food. So for me and my dogs we want to thank you for everything that you have become chewy.com.

She loves them, they're healthy don't cause her flare up issues with her skin and allergies, and high quality ingredients. We've bought and used these and this brand for since January and we will stick with them!