Natural Balance L.I.D. Limited Ingredient Diets White Fish & Sweet Potato Formula Flaked Grain-Free Wet Dog Food, 2.75-oz, case of 24

Read all the complaints, held my nose (pardon the pun) and ordered it anyway. Is it pungent? well duhh, it's fish what does anyone expect? Bones? Sure but dogs eat thicker/heavier bones than that, AND as my daddy all ways said, "a few fish bones won't hurt you son!" The only criticism I agreed with is, DANG this food is expensive! Bottom-line it smells great to the fur-baby (and she is finicky). I use it as a topper to get her to eat the regular dry food, so we are almost down to the last container; I will reorder...

This and the other fish flavors of Natural Balance seem to have small fish bones. We found several. We contacted Chewy to make them aware and they didn't seem very concerned. We are dealing with the company over this now. Not even a warning on the label about it. I have very small dogs and this is scary. So beware and if you buy this, check it very carefully for the fish bones.

I purchased this wet food for my three dogs (2 pitbull mixes and a Siberian husky) as a special treat to add to their kibble on occasion. One dog has a chicken allergy so it is very hard to find a wet food that she can have. This was to replace the Natural Balance Chop Lickin Stew which my dogs loved but has been unavailable from multiple pet retailers. This is a much smaller container (yet same price) and has a strong fish odor - like I have to rinse the empty container and put it in a zip lock bag before throwing it out so my trash doesn't stink. When I mixed it into their kibble I was disappointed with the small amount of fish. It was mostly gravy and sweet potatoes. My biggest concern I purchased this wet food for my three dogs (2 pitbull mixes and a Siberian husky) as a special treat to add to their kibble on occasion. One dog has a chicken allergy so it is very hard to find a wet food that she can have. This was to replace the Natural Balance Chop Lickin Stew which my dogs loved but has been unavailable from multiple pet retailers. This is a much smaller container (yet same price) and has a strong fish odor - like I have to rinse the empty container and put it in a zip lock bag before throwing it out so my trash doesn't stink. When I mixed it into their kibble I was disappointed with the small amount of fish. It was mostly gravy and sweet potatoes. My biggest concern was finding MULTIPLE fish bones in all but one of the containers that we have used thus far. I had to sort through it to get them out prior to feeding my dogs. From what I have read, dogs ingesting fish bones would likely be fine but there is no reason to risk it when other products were better quality. The previous product we bought contained large chunks of tuna, did not have as strong of an odor, and I never saw a bone in it over the past three years. I wish that one was still available. In summary, my dogs thoroughly enjoyed it and licked their bowls clean but I would much rather have a product with more meat and not have to worry about checking for bones. … more

Beware- this food contains bones! I cannot believe they are still selling it. Not just small pin bones, but some very large- the width of toothpicks! Thank goodness I noticed them before feeding it my German Shepherd as a kibble topper.

I was all excited because I thought my dog would love this food. I opened it up and omg what strong fish order. I thought ok dogs like stinky things. I set the plate down she sniffed it and she ran! Yes you read that right she took off running. So I went and got her...put a bite in her mouth, she spit it out and ran again! So I'm gunna say this food is a big no for my girl.

My dig has allergies and this is one of the few foods he can eat.

I ordered this food as a topper for our super sensitive EPI dog. Everyone that owns a dog with this disease knows how little can throw them off and cause a flare up even with adding extra enzyme. Having a combination of a picky eater PLUS EPI pretty much turns feeding time into a nightmare. If they accept it, they might not do well on it and have a flare up or might develop an allergic reaction (he’s also allergic to any form of poultry and dairy - oh joy!) In this case, I am so happy to report that he not only LOVES the addition of this wet food, but also, didn’t develop diarrhea or any other symptoms as he often does when we switch up the food. We are now feeding this in combination with Earth I ordered this food as a topper for our super sensitive EPI dog. Everyone that owns a dog with this disease knows how little can throw them off and cause a flare up even with adding extra enzyme. Having a combination of a picky eater PLUS EPI pretty much turns feeding time into a nightmare. If they accept it, they might not do well on it and have a flare up or might develop an allergic reaction (he’s also allergic to any form of poultry and dairy - oh joy!) In this case, I am so happy to report that he not only LOVES the addition of this wet food, but also, didn’t develop diarrhea or any other symptoms as he often does when we switch up the food. We are now feeding this in combination with Earth Born Holistic Coastal Catch and haven’t had a flare up ever since! I was a little worried about reports regarding the smell, but after feeding our other dogs raw for a decade and occasionally feeding raw fish, this is nothing to worry about in the smells department. I find that a basic can of tuna smells stronger and leaves a stronger smell on my hands when handling it. … more

My dog loves the white fish and sweet potato flavors and when I open it, he starts a special dance and vocalizations that are his versions of a happy song.

My dog has a beef and chicken allergy, so finding food is already difficult, then his flavor was discontinued, so i bought him a case of the fish. Nope, poor guy would rather starve himself then even go near his dish.

Yes, my dog laps this up. I buy this fish flavor and the Wooferole (because he is allergic to chicken, which is in all the other flavors), and mix a small amount with his kibble to make a gravy. My only criticism with the fish flavor is that there's more gravy than fish, unlike the other flavors, which have more "meat." It's kind of expensive for a tub of mostly gravy.