My dogs love these and nutritionally they were exactly what I wanted. The only downside is the serving instructions are per piece by dog weight but the pieces are all broken up in the bag. So while the treats are great and loved by my dogs, they were a hassle for me to dispense the correct amount. I solved this by dumping the whole bag in the food processor and mixing in enough coconut oil to get the consistency of thick peanut butter. I then put this mixture in a candy mold and refrigerated to harden. After hardening, I had consistently sized pieces for serving and they sliced easily for portioning to the smallest pooch. Obviously, I store the prepared batch in the refrigerator so they remain in the hardened state. I do think this treat is worth the extra effort.