Puppy Chow Healthy Start Salmon Flavor Training Dog Treats

This is a great treat especially with the amount you get for the price it's not really the best ingredients but all my dogs seem to enjoy it I even tend to train my oldest (3 years) with it but I would recomend brands like wellness soft puppy bites or the entire American journey training treats (soft and chewy) line which are sold here on chewy for around the same price with better ingredients and my dog actually tends to like them better but I use the puppy chow treats as a medium to low value and the others I listed as a mid-high value but if you want a really high value treat for your dog I recomend just going to the store or thru your freezer and find the cheapest meat (I suggest chicken) This is a great treat especially with the amount you get for the price it's not really the best ingredients but all my dogs seem to enjoy it I even tend to train my oldest (3 years) with it but I would recomend brands like wellness soft puppy bites or the entire American journey training treats (soft and chewy) line which are sold here on chewy for around the same price with better ingredients and my dog actually tends to like them better but I use the puppy chow treats as a medium to low value and the others I listed as a mid-high value but if you want a really high value treat for your dog I recomend just going to the store or thru your freezer and find the cheapest meat (I suggest chicken) boil it plain and watch your dog go crazy over it and be successful during training but I hoped this review helped anybody looking for good treat recommendations to train their dog with have a great day<3 … more

I wasn't aware these training treats had an expiration date. I ordered them in March and they expired in June. I went to use the treats in July and half the bag was a lump of mold. It was one ball of white fuzz. I've used many different training treats for years and have never had this problem before.

We've been using these treats to train our Aussie puppy since she was 8 weeks old. She is now 20 weeks old and she still loves them! We are on our third bag. I love how tiny these treats are, and you can either break them in half easily or keep them whole—either way, they are small and the perfect size for training. You also cannot beat the value—this is a huge bag for a small price and lasts a while depending on the frequency of your training/treating.

I bought these treats because we got a new puppy. They have been great to train him. He loves them as does his two big sisters. The treats are small and have an indentation down the middle and I have been breaking them in half to train him. He’s small so it’s enough and will make the bag last longer.

My puppy was not super interested in these and he could barely chew them. I think they were too sticky for him (like a fruit snack or Dots candy for humans). I will choose crunchy treats in the future.

I’m sure they are awesome, but my pup won’t eat them. They are a little large for him but he still doesn’t like them when I cut them up.

I bought these to use my with JRT puppy. She likes them and we’ve almost finished the bag. You can break each treat in half to double the treats. I took one star off because they can get a little stale and hard if you don’t reseal well.

My puppy loves these! I love how low in calories they are so i can give them to her throughout the day when training her.

I bought these for when I brought my pup home for the first time--she was eating Purina puppy chicken kibble, so I figured this was a safectreat to start her off with. She would eat them about half the time they were offered to her. I kept them in a little pouch that I took on walks and they get stale quickly. I ended up throwing half the bag out.

I'm trying a variety of treats as we do training for our puppy (toy poodle). He does not seem to like these as much as some other treats. I'm not giving up on them yet because the price point is excellent and there's a lot of training to be done.