I opened these and was struck by the stink, but hey, some treats are stinky, right? Thank goodness I looked in the bag before sticking my hand in to dole out treats to the dogs! Ugh! Webbing and decay! Checked the best by date - still months off, so supposed to be good, but NO WAY. Right into the outside trash can. Handed out freeze dried salmon treats from Whole Life, instead. Whole Life is always top quality and safe, thank goodness! Don't know what was wrong with these, but won't be trusting Roam products, again.