Small Pet Select First Cut Timothy Hay Small Animal Food

By Small Pet Select
Rated 4.4057 out of 5 stars


Selected: Size:


Selected: Size:

$32.99Chewy Price
$31.34Autoship Price
Autoship (Save an extra 5%)

Why Autoship?

  • Save 5% on all future Autoship orders
  • Set your schedule based on your pet's needs
  • No fees, no commitments - skip, change or cancel anytime.
In Stock
FREE delivery on first-time orders over $35
Arrives between Dec 09 and Dec 17

About This Item


  • This 1st cutting hay provides your small pet with a high-fiber hay source, containing more fiber than other types of cuttings.
  • Can help little pals who need more fiber for chronic GI or digestive system issues.
  • This hay is soft, leafy and has more flower heads than other cuttings—a tasty way for your little pal to get fiber.
  • Features high-quality, fresh hay from the current crop year.
  • Made in the USA by a small, family-owned business.

See More

Nutritional Information

Feeding Instructions

Frequently Bought Together

Small Pet Select Timothy Based Rabbit Food, 10-lb bag
Rated 5 out of 5 stars
$29.99Chewy Price
Oxbow Enriched Life Willow Play Cube Small Animal Toy
Rated 4.5614 out of 5 stars
$5.97Chewy Price

Buy 2, Get 3rd Free- Mix & Match

Total Price: $68.95

Compare Similar Items

Customer Rating
Rated 4.4057 out of 5 stars
Rated 4.3913 out of 5 stars
Rated 4.0069 out of 5 stars
Rated 3.5108 out of 5 stars
Rated 3.3628 out of 5 stars
$32.99Chewy Price
$33.99Chewy Price
$49.47Chewy Price
$22.22Chewy Price
$23.40Chewy Price
$31.34Chewy Price
$32.29Chewy Price
$47.00Chewy Price
$21.11Chewy Price
$22.23Chewy Price
Top Ingredients100% Timothy Hay100% Timothy HaySecond Cutting Timothy Hay.Timothy Hay.Timothy Hay.
Small Pet TypeRabbit, Guinea Pig, Chinchilla, DeguRabbit, Guinea Pig, Chinchilla, DeguRabbit, Guinea Pig, Chinchilla, DeguRabbit, Guinea Pig, Gerbil, HamsterRabbit, Guinea Pig, Gerbil, Hamster
Hay TypeTimothyTimothyTimothyTimothyTimothy
Food FormHayHayHayHayHay
Health FeatureDental & Breath Care, Digestive Health
Special DietLow-Protein, High Fiber

Questions & Answers

Be the first to ask a question.

ReviewsWrite a Review

Rated 4.4057 out of 5 stars
106 Ratings
Would recommend to a friend

106 Customer Reviews

Rated 2 out of 5 stars
By kristina on Oct 11, 2023

too much "straw"

Been ordering this brand of Timothy hay for years but this time it was mostly "straw" and all 3 pets wouldn't eat it. I have ordered second cutting in the past which they loved-- but first cutting shouldn't mean "straw".

Rated 5 out of 5 stars
By Elizabeth on May 28, 2023


This is a 10 STARS product. We have 5 guinea pigs and 2 home built habitats. This hay was FRESH! The box was heavily packed, and the guinea pigs LOVE it. The unexpected benefit was how easy it was to work with. By the time I had emptied the box out I knew I had to send a great review. It was so easy to cut handfuls out with heavy shears, (not included). I have a second full box but my Aussie, who loves the piggies, tried to open it for me. It's messy but still useable.

Rated 1 out of 5 stars
By hay1cut on Jul 23, 2023

turned brown/tan quick

Some of it was brown/tan when it arrived when it should be a green color. It all turned brown/tan after a couple of days and my guinea pigs refuse to eat it. Quite disappointed.

Rated 3 out of 5 stars
By ltlbett on May 22, 2023

So messy, straw-like

My guineas eat it, but to me seems more like straw than anything else. Biggest complaint is the mess level. Difficult to get out of the box without it going everywhere, then it's a struggle to close the box up. Definitely wont be buying this one again.

Rated 5 out of 5 stars
By Smore on May 11, 2023

New favorite hay

Safe to say my picky rabbit, S’more loves this hay. It’s fresh, green, crunchy with a lot less dust than most brands. She has megacolon and this is definitely helping her digestive system. Finally a quality hay!

Rated 1 out of 5 stars
By ToffeetheBunny on Apr 8, 2023


It came in with only this large paper box with no other covers, only a pick of tape to keep it closed. When I opened it, the middle part looks burned and moldy, and lots of powder when I flipped this part, made my nose feel wired. This is definitely not good.

Rated 1 out of 5 stars
By BADHAYDAY on Feb 6, 2023

horrible hay

This hay was awful! It was long and hard, very much like just a tube of hard straw plastic. My bunnies would only really pull it out and pee on it. I ordered a large bulk of it, being 3 boxes (30 pounds) and because my rabbits hated it, I was just going through it constantly, going through over 20 pounds in just under a month. I was hoping it was gonna last me quite a while but oh boy was I wrong. Horrible product! I wish I never bought it.

Rated 1 out of 5 stars
By whiskers on Jan 12, 2023

inedible and disappointing

I had high hopes from the reviews and photos, but the batch I received is dessicated, yellow, not fresh straw that is completely refused by my rabbits. I left their hay feeder full as I went tovwork in the office for 12 hours and returned to the hay thrown around everywhere and the babies hated it so much they went into GI stasis rather than trying to stomach the horrible product we received. Really such a let down :(

Rated 5 out of 5 stars
By Jamt on Mar 15, 2023

Best Timothy Hay

I used to purchased a different popular brand hay but saw quality go down hill. Tried Small Pet Select. My rabbit loves his new hay and eats it happily

Rated 1 out of 5 stars
By ChalupaNAstrid on Jan 6, 2023

Not good, straw-like and dry

I'm really disappointed in this hay, especially for the price. It is completely dry and old. It's so yellow it looks like straw. It also feels like straw with large stems and no grass. My rabbits won't eat it at all and I'm not sure I should keep trying. It looks well over a few months old.