SmartBones SmartSticks Peanut Butter Chews Dog Treats

Let’s be honest. My dog is big(ish)— but he’s also pretty gentle with his toys and treats. One of these lasted him maybe 2 minutes, which given his size is actually pretty admirable! He also LOVES them— he went through his entire repertoire of tricks to get one and was very motivated to learn new ones that required a lot of attention to learn. I wouldn’t get them for him as a treat to occupy him for a long time, but I’ll get them again for scent work and other more complex training because of how much he loves them!

Raleigh opens his cabinet door and chooses this treat above all others!! He is a very pampered 8 lb yorkie bichon who eats very properly and wants me to cut the sticks in small pieces or pull the layers apart. He ate the peanut butter chips from this same brand but I had to cut them into small pieces. I wish they made this in a smaller treat for sensitive little gentle rascals like mine.. but for now I must go on cutting the hard chewy pieces for his pampered little mouth ! They smell like real peanut butter and contains no rawhide and he loves it!

I have no idea what they taste like. I got them as an easy way to get over the free shipping limit. But Turbo tells me they are very good and is enthusiastic when it is time for a snack. Don't ask me about the rating. When I offer them to Turbo (his real nickname is Bo, but website need 4 letters), he wags his tail at 4 on a scale of 5. He is always truthful, so that is reliable. I think that his rating is only four because it is all over in about two minutes and he wants more.

The dogs seem to like these. They take a minute or two longer to eat than, say, Greenies. However, the when you pull the top off the "resealable" packaging it is completely sealed. So you have to cut under the "resealable" part, making it pointless. If you have some other way to store them, then this is not an issue.

Our pup did not care for peanut butter bones or cookies, so I was surprised when he took the stick and scurried off to the family room. I leaned down to move him over so I could finish vacuuming. He raised his nose and lifted one lip. He has never done such a thing, ever. Of course he didn't mean it, but that stuff must be good!

My dog Ziggy wanted nothing to do with these smart treats which are rolled neatly into sticks. I thought it was a good idea since they were peanut butter flavored. He actually really likes the white chewy ones shaped like bones.

I got these for my 9 week old 20 pound Akita puppy to give him occasionally to keep him occupied. He loves them, but they don't last him more than ten or fifteen minutes tops. Though these aren't very long lasting, they are a nice snack for the pups. They don't have a strong/gross smell like many treats. I would recommend these.

First time trying this and so far, all the dogs love it. I only have one dog but the word is out and I found I had to treat the other dogs that came calling. These are a bit big compared to the sticks so I limit to just once in a while. But you know, I love just about every thing I've bought from Chewy.

We have a 30lb pug/terrier mix. The treats are a great size to keep him happy for an hour or so. He’s a heavy chewer so he plows through them fast but he loves them. They do leave a peanut butter smell wherever he was chewing. Nothing we aren’t used to with other treats but don’t let them chew on your couch unless you enjoy the scent

Both our 10 year old Shina and 3 month old Poodle absolutely love these. I wish they would last a little longer, but one of these will keep them occupied for at least 15 minutes, and I can’t complain about the PB smell (as opposed to their other faves, bully sticks)!