Tuffy's Jr 3WayTug Dog Toy
The girls tear at this thing but it lasts and lasts. I tie a rope to it so we can circle it over head and the border collie leaps to catch.
Our Lab, Tasha, loves playing with this toy. My kids play fetch and tug with her for quite a while. It's great taking to the park. We've washed it a couple times and it holds up really well.