The bag holder is great, the fabric pouch is much easier to load than the hard plastic ones. The wipe holder is disappointing. It is awkward for actually attaching to a leash which was my intention. It is also disappointing there are no options for wipes to fill the holder, it can hold up to 22 wipes which is not a typical quantity so are you supposed to cram a 24 pack of a random brand in there hoping it will fit or remove a handful from a large pack to put in there loose and hope they don’t dry out? Honestly I’m more likely to just keep using a ziploc baggie stuff with acme wipes.