Cloud Star Tricky Trainers Chewy Grain Free Peanut Butter Flavor Dog Treats

They don't look or smell grain free. Soft and chewy, they look and smell like cut up bite size slim Jim's. I may or may not have almost eaten one myself. Dog will do anything for one or 2...or 6! The pleading eyes kill me. My only complaint is the bag is hard to get the zipper to stay closed, and I often find it popped open again after I walk away knowing I sealed it well. This is our first bag so don't know if it is a design flaw or just a problem with this one bag. We will be buying again very soon the way he is eating them and will let you know. Even if this is a repeat issue, I will still buy them regularly and just get a reusable container for them.

These are great little treats. My shihtzu is allergic to a lot of things, but Cloud Star has some great treats that do not have rice, chicken, wheat, eggs, milk, to name a few. I use these on our walk, as well as just every day treats in the house.

It's great to know these are high quality and grain free. Max LOVES these and will never spit them out. It's one of the few he will actually voluntarily come to when he see's it. Soft to sprinkle over food. A+

I like the grain free contents and the size of the treat.

He loves them and they can be broken down into 3 pieces or so for training if you want to cut back on how much they are eating haha. No overweight corgi for us. Also, his breath doesn’t smell like some other treats we’ve tried that are also grain free

My dog loves peanut butter, so those were a for-sure hit. However, Cloud Star added a smoky flavor, so they’re kind of BBQ-peanut butter. Odd, but still yummy good training treats!

My Bella a very picky Bichon loved them & since she’s sensitive to grain, the grain free was perfect!

Our 2 puppies just can’t wait for these treats. They love training with these tricky trainers and have become great listeners - they have made training so easy, thank you!

These look like a perfect small, and special, treat. I was, however, surprised when I opened the package and wondered why it smelled of barbecue instead of peanut butter. My fault: I didn't read the ingredients carefully before ordering. The culprit is "natural smoke flavoring," an additive I prefer to avoid for myself and for dogs. I also don't want the strong smell in my pocket. If you don't mind smoke flavoring, you and your dogs will probably like these a lot. Just don't tell my dog. I had to say, "Woops, I made a mistake" and disappear them.

I know these usually are a training treat, but my dog is 16, and she loves these. On our way home from a walk, she will literally stop and wait till I give her one, and five, etc. They are small and soft, and low fat, perfect for my baby.