I ordered several different treats, to try to find some good ones to train with, unfortunately these missed that mark. However, they are great for one time rewards, such as going potty, coming when called, or just random reinforcing rewards for known behaviors. They do not work well for learning new commands, or things that will require multiple rewards quickly. My dogs do love them, and they smell very flavorful. It says they are chewy, but they are a bit too chewy. They are pretty firm, and sometimes I hear a small crunch when my dogs eat them. It tends to take them about 3 seconds to eat one. I will probably purchase them again, but next time not for training.
I have ordered these treats one time. On 11-10-2020 I ordered 5 bags of these treats and they were delivered to my home on 11-15-2020. They were hard as a rock. I looked at the expiration date on the bag and they expired on 12-12-2019. My dog liked them so I kept them, but unless Chewy.com replaces them, I will not order from them again. I have ordered many other things from them over the years, but no more. Almost a year outdated was too much for me...
Worst bag of treats I've purchased. They are rock hard, probably stale, and my dog won't eat them. Going straight to the trash.
My 2 month old Golden Retriever absolutely loves these! I have other training treats I've given him and he definitely prefers these. My GSD also loves these too! Will be buying again.
I bought two bags of these when they went on sale and I plan on buying a few more! These are decently sized training treats. I’d love them a lot more if they were easier to break apart but I can’t complain too much. The smell is strong but decent. My dog comes running as soon as he smells them. I love these treats a lot but with how my pup goes through training treats, I probably won’t be buying these unless they are on sale with how expensive they are for how many treats are in the bag. (I am speaking as someone who uses treats EXCLUSIVELY for training. I definitely think they are worth it if you aren’t going through nearly a whole bag of training treats a day in the first place)
These are great, affordable treats. They smell strong so they are good for training, and they don't crumble. I wish they were a little smaller, but I just break them in half.
My dogs love them (but they love everything), but they were a little hard for my liking.
They smell good and my dogs seem to think they taste delicious so I guess they are good!
She goes crazy after these perfect for taking to her training classes
My 8 month old lab loves it. They get her to listen ! She only listens when I have bacon apple in my hand . Smh . It’s good though!!