I had bought this last year and cats loved it. However, now I bought it again, my cats refuse to touch it. Maybe the formula has changed.
My cats love Earthborn and normally we feed them the blue can. I picked up some other varieties at a local pet shop to see if they liked any other flavors. They loved the orange one so I decided to order a case from Chewy. Well suddenly they will no longer eat it. I dont know what the difference is between the cans at my local pet shop versus the cans from Chewy but it is very strange. As others have said these ones also have a lot more liquid in them. Some of the fish is in huge chunks and my cats struggle when trying to eat it. Huge waste of money since this stuff is not cheap. Will stick with the green cans.
This stuff smells horrible. So horrible even my cats think it stinks! They usually enjoy stinky cat food, but this stuffs not a good stink!
I have purchased two cases of this food in the past and it was excellent. Packed with fish. My cats loved it. However the third time I ordered it, it was all liquid. Barely any fish at all. Very disappointing. Won’t buy again. Also noticed that other reviews said the same thing. I’ve also purchased the Harbor Harvest and again, the third case I bought, half of the cans were very badly dented. I think there are some production quality issues with Earthborn Holistic Foods.
My Maine Coon cat, who loves this brand, would not eat this variety. It looked terrific and what cat wouldn’t love mackerel and shrimp? My guy.
This is a great food and our cats love it, but just be carefull opening the cans as this is in a very watery sauce and it is easy to spill some when opening.
like all ways excellent shipping and product and like all ways it was shipped very fast and they let you know how and when they are shipping
This is the only flavor out of the earthborn flavors my cat will not eat... it's a waste of money
Compared to the other Earthborn canned cat food, Catalina Catch is extremely watery and not as much actual food. The photo is just after opening the can.
Cans are so watery that I have to drain most of the fluid before feeding it up my cat. Once drained there's less than half of the can left. Also my cat doesn't like it.