My puppy loves these. The regular Himalayan dog chews are way too hard for a puppy, but these are much softer. Perfect for a puppy that is testing out new adult teeth. If you have an adult dog or a extreme chewer, these will last less than 5 minutes. My friend's adult corgi devours these as though she is a vacuum.
These are a very FIRM HARD DENSITY- Not soft like it says on the container or the description listed, I have small bulldogs and they said NO Way can we eat these Mommy. For large or giant dogs these are probably edible. I will pour hot water over them, soak awhile & maybe it will become a gravy.