Pupford Calming String Cheese Flavored Soft Chew Calming Supplement for Puppies, 60 count

I like that they have natural ingredients and are approved for puppies. But, they haven’t had much of an effect. I won’t reorder for him, as a puppy, but my daughter’s adult dog does better on calming chews during fireworks or if they’re going out for a few hours.

I swear by this ! Both dogs are restless at night so I found giving them a calmer by chew helps them both

I got these after we adopted a 5 month old puppy who was mistreated for the 2 months before we adopted her. She started showing severe anxiety when my husband or I left, crying loudly for long periods of time and scratching at the front door, even if one of us was still here. I can only imagine how bad it was when we were both gone! I give this to her about an hour before we go somewhere, if I can, and it calms her down enough that she is okay with one of us leaving for a short time (and I am guessing when we are both gone as well). We also had a thunderstorm last week, which was her first since we have had her. She was whimpering every time it thundered so I gave her one of these. It does seem to take a bit to start working so the thunderstorm was almost over by the time it kicked in but we know that when we get the alerts for storms, to give her one at that time. All in all, I am pretty happy with this and will buy more when needed to have on hand.