I bought Purina treats that had shrimp in them. She blew through the bag in under two weeks (small bag). Couldn’t find them again so I ordered the 1lb size of Temptations shrimp treats. If she didn’t like them, we could use them for the strays. Not. An. Issue. She ate through 2/3 of the tub by herself between when I bought them and a month later (last week) when we adopted one of those strays (who also loves them but is not as shrimp obsessed as her. So 5/5, 1/1 (1, honestly, why do we never reduce these fractions?), full marks. These are a must-have in our house or we humans will be murdered. Or worse: they’ll give us the Sad Eyes.

My order had a lot of loose items in a great big carton. It also included a 40lb container of litter, that shifted during delivery. This crushed a number of the softer items emptying out their contents. This has been the worst delivery out of the many years of doing business with them. Unless they do something about correcting packing issues going forward, this may be the last time I order from chewy. Customer service could have been better.

My eight-year-old cat goes crazy for this. I think it’s a very healthy food. The kibble is nice and small. And the smell is very noticeable and nice, but not overpowering.