PREMIUM CHOICE Carefree All Natural Unscented Clumping Clay Cat Litter, 40-lb bag -

Premium Choice Carefree Unscented Clumping Clay Cat Litter

By Premium Choice
Rated 3.7936 out of 5 stars

New Customers Only: Spend 49+ Get $20 off + Free Shipping with code: NEWCHEWY

See Details for instructions to redeem.
$21.99Chewy Price
$20.89Autoship Price
(Save an extra 5%)

Why Autoship?

  • Save 5% on all future Autoship orders
  • Set your schedule based on your pet's needs
  • No fees, no commitments - skip, change or cancel anytime.

In Stock
FREE 1-3 day shipping over $49

About This Item


  • Formulated to neutralizes odors naturally without chemical additives or fragrances. Perfect for cats that are sensitive to fragrances or additives.
  • Perfect for households with multiple cats. Not only does this product have superior clumping but it also has low-tracking and low dust.
  • Premium choice litter contains the fewest additives possible and is all-natural, naturally.
  • The best formula is ironically the most basic – the purest clay and sodium bentonite available. This product is made with the purest clay and sodium bentonite available.
  • The clay is produced directly by Premium Choice. They mine, convert, package and deliver their own clay.

See More


Play Video: Learn More About Premium Choice From Our Team of Experts
Learn More About Premium Choice From Our Team of Experts

Questions & Answers

10 Customer Questions

Where is this litter made?
Answer by ChewyMay 13, 2018
This litter is made in the United States.

Hi, about how many cups of litter do you get in the 40 lb bag?
Answer by ChewyOct 19, 2020
There will be approximately 1.97 cups per pound of litter. The 16 pound bag will have 31.52 cups, the 25 pound bag will have 49.25 cups, the 40 pound bag will have 78.8 cups, and the 50 pound bag will have 98.5 cups.

Would this be considered a lightweight litter or standard?
Answer by ChewyJun 06, 2018
This litter is considered a standard clay litter.

Does this litter contain baking soda? My cat will not use litter with baking soda in it.
Answer by ChewySep 13, 2018
This litter does not contain baking soda. All of the Premium Choice all natural varieties are baking soda free.

ReviewsWrite a Review

Rated 3.7936 out of 5 stars
470 Ratings
Would recommend to a friend

470 Customer Reviews

Rated 1 out of 5 stars
By Elizabeth on May 8, 2023


This litter has always been a solid "good enough" for us - it clumps hard, it is dusty (like hold you breath when you pour it dusty) and even though it does nothing when it comes to hiding kitty smell, at least it doesn't stink up your room with fake perfume scent... but what the heck?! Doubling in price?! Seriously?! I have taken this off my auto shipments now because I was seriously mad about that. Finding another brand that's either cheaper, or better quality for the price that they are now price-gouging us on.

Rated 2 out of 5 stars
By Charlie6 on Jun 3, 2023

Very dusty

I love the fact that this is unscented and that it’s available in bags not plastic pails. The amount of dust was intolerable though. I guess I’ll keep searching.

Rated 1 out of 5 stars
By RavynsMom on May 5, 2023

gave my cat a UTI

I loved how it clumped very hard. However after a few days my baby developed her first ever UTI. very disappointing but I don’t blame the company. She might just be sensitive. So sensitive cats, beware.

Rated 1 out of 5 stars
By savvyshopper on Apr 5, 2023

Almost doubled in price!!!

I was happy enough with this cat litter the first time I ordered it 2 months ago. It was a good price for a 40# bag (which is a bigger bag than I usually care to handle but selected it based on the price.) I was shocked to see the increased amount on my autoship! The price increased by 83%!!! I'm now shopping for a cheaper litter for my kitty to poop in.

Rated 2 out of 5 stars
By Kat on May 18, 2023


Did not like this product at all, it already had some small clumps when I opened bag. Very dusty too. Didn't like the clumping ability either.

Rated 2 out of 5 stars
By Mamacat on Mar 15, 2023

Not working for us...

I purchased several bags of this litter, at first it seemed very nice, I liked the consistency of it, fairly good odor control and especially the price, however, about one to two weeks into it , I started to notice high tracking throughout the house and litter stuck between every ones toes, we had to stop using it...

Rated 2 out of 5 stars
By Muggle on Mar 18, 2023

It was great....

I bought this because the price had gone up on our old brand of choice, so I wanted to try this to see if we could save money. WOW! It worked just as well as the old brand and was so much cheaper! Now I see that the price jumped up to over $20 a bag!?!? That's a huge difference in price in a very short amount of time! I'm glad I checked before the autoshipment went out again!

Rated 4 out of 5 stars
By sumkitteh on Jun 2, 2023

The bag was very hard to open

A great great dea on good litter - opening the package was painful given the mobility issues I have, here -

Rated 4 out of 5 stars
By jsb595 on May 9, 2023

Litter pricing

Loved this litter and pricing however, overnight the price increased $10+ . Happy I caught before my autoship and am now looking for another brand.

Rated 5 out of 5 stars
By Michelle on Feb 23, 2023

Satisfied Customer

I'm going to be honest: I have 4 indoor cats and I just wanted the cheapest cat litter I could find. Having 40 pounds of cat litter delivered right to my door was unbeatable for this price! I had to try it out and I am 100% satisfied. I actually did a side-by-side comparison of Premium Choice vs. Tidy Cats (which was recommended by my friend). I filled one litter box up with premium choice and the other with Tidy Cats. There is no doubt about it, Premium Choice wins! It clumped perfectly and I don't think it's very dusty at all. I didn't notice any extra odors but I'm not very sensitive to that either (I've changed a lot of diapers!) Of course it smells when the cats first go but after that, I did not notice anything lingering in the air. I'll definitely be buying this again.