10 Best Temptations Cat Treats 2026: According to Reviews | Chewy

The 10 Best Temptations Cat Treats

Jump to the list

How we created this temptations cat treat list

We leveraged input from our veterinarians and artificial intelligence to identify key considerations to help you find the best temptations cat treat.
We scanned thousands of customer reviews and ratings and scored each product based on its performance against each of the key considerations. We then considered how popular a product is with Chewy customers and combined that with its key consideration scores to create the list of the best temptations cat treats.

Key temptations cat treat considerations

Flavor options

Nutritional value

Palatability

Texture

1
Temptations Classic Tasty Chicken Flavor Soft & Crunchy Cat Treats, 16-oz tub
Temptations Classic Tasty Chicken Flavor Soft & Crunchy Cat Treats, 16-oz tub
Temptations Classic Tasty Chicken Flavor Soft & Crunchy Cat Treats, 16-oz tub
Temptations Classic Tasty Chicken Flavor Soft & Crunchy Cat Treats, 16-oz tub
Temptations Classic Tasty Chicken Flavor Soft & Crunchy Cat Treats, 16-oz tub
Temptations Classic Tasty Chicken Flavor Soft & Crunchy Cat Treats, 16-oz tub
Temptations Classic Tasty Chicken Flavor Soft & Crunchy Cat Treats, 16-oz tub
Temptations Classic Tasty Chicken Flavor Soft & Crunchy Cat Treats, 16-oz tub
Temptations Classic Tasty Chicken Flavor Soft & Crunchy Cat Treats, 16-oz tub

Temptations Classic Tasty Chicken Flavor Soft & Crunchy Cat Treats, 16-oz tub

Rated 4.8 out of 5 stars
37,644
$8.48 Chewy Price
($0.53/oz)
Promo, New Customers Only: Spend $49+, get $20 off

Our ratings

Flavor options

4.7/5
Excellent

Nutritional value

4.6/5
Excellent

Palatability

4.5/5
Great

Texture

4.6/5
Excellent

Is this temptations cat treat right for my pet?

Lifestage

All Lifestages, Adult

Top Ingredients

Chicken By-Product Meal, Ground Corn, Animal Fat (Preserved With Mixed Tocopherols), Wheat Flour, Brewers Rice

Food Flavor

Chicken, Poultry

Packaging Type

Tub
2
Temptations MixUps Catnip Fever Flavor Soft & Crunchy Cat Treats, 16-oz tub
Temptations MixUps Catnip Fever Flavor Soft & Crunchy Cat Treats, 16-oz tub
Temptations MixUps Catnip Fever Flavor Soft & Crunchy Cat Treats, 16-oz tub
Temptations MixUps Catnip Fever Flavor Soft & Crunchy Cat Treats, 16-oz tub
Temptations MixUps Catnip Fever Flavor Soft & Crunchy Cat Treats, 16-oz tub
Temptations MixUps Catnip Fever Flavor Soft & Crunchy Cat Treats, 16-oz tub
Temptations MixUps Catnip Fever Flavor Soft & Crunchy Cat Treats, 16-oz tub
Temptations MixUps Catnip Fever Flavor Soft & Crunchy Cat Treats, 16-oz tub
Temptations MixUps Catnip Fever Flavor Soft & Crunchy Cat Treats, 16-oz tub

Temptations MixUps Catnip Fever Flavor Soft & Crunchy Cat Treats, 16-oz tub

Rated 4.8 out of 5 stars
20,543
$8.48 Chewy Price
($0.53/oz)
Promo, New Customers Only: Spend $49+, get $20 off

Our ratings

Flavor options

4.7/5
Excellent

Nutritional value

4.6/5
Excellent

Palatability

4.5/5
Great

Texture

4.6/5
Excellent

Is this temptations cat treat right for my pet?

Lifestage

All Lifestages, Adult

Top Ingredients

Chicken By-Product Meal, Ground Corn, Animal Fat (Preserved With Mixed Tocopherols), Wheat Flour, Brewers Rice

Food Flavor

Chicken, Cheese, Catnip

Packaging Type

Tub
3
Temptations Classic Seafood Medley Flavor Soft & Crunchy Cat Treats, 30-oz tub
Temptations Classic Seafood Medley Flavor Soft & Crunchy Cat Treats, 30-oz tub
Temptations Classic Seafood Medley Flavor Soft & Crunchy Cat Treats, 30-oz tub
Temptations Classic Seafood Medley Flavor Soft & Crunchy Cat Treats, 30-oz tub
Temptations Classic Seafood Medley Flavor Soft & Crunchy Cat Treats, 30-oz tub
Temptations Classic Seafood Medley Flavor Soft & Crunchy Cat Treats, 30-oz tub
Temptations Classic Seafood Medley Flavor Soft & Crunchy Cat Treats, 30-oz tub
Temptations Classic Seafood Medley Flavor Soft & Crunchy Cat Treats, 30-oz tub
Temptations Classic Seafood Medley Flavor Soft & Crunchy Cat Treats, 30-oz tub

Temptations Classic Seafood Medley Flavor Soft & Crunchy Cat Treats, 30-oz tub

Rated 4.8 out of 5 stars
13,588
$15.48 Chewy Price
($0.52/oz)
Promo, New Customers Only: Spend $49+, get $20 off

Our ratings

Flavor options

4.7/5
Excellent

Nutritional value

4.5/5
Great

Palatability

4.4/5
Great

Texture

4.5/5
Great

Is this temptations cat treat right for my pet?

Lifestage

All Lifestages, Adult

Top Ingredients

Chicken By-Product Meal, Ground Corn, Animal Fat (Preserved With Mixed Tocopherols), Wheat Flour, Brewers Rice

Food Flavor

Seafood & Fish

Packaging Type

Tub
4
Temptations ShakeUps Crustacean Celebration Lobster, Crab & Shrimp Flavor Soft & Crunchy Cat Treats, 5.29-oz bag
Temptations ShakeUps Crustacean Celebration Lobster, Crab & Shrimp Flavor Soft & Crunchy Cat Treats, 5.29-oz bag
Temptations ShakeUps Crustacean Celebration Lobster, Crab & Shrimp Flavor Soft & Crunchy Cat Treats, 5.29-oz bag
Temptations ShakeUps Crustacean Celebration Lobster, Crab & Shrimp Flavor Soft & Crunchy Cat Treats, 5.29-oz bag
Temptations ShakeUps Crustacean Celebration Lobster, Crab & Shrimp Flavor Soft & Crunchy Cat Treats, 5.29-oz bag
Temptations ShakeUps Crustacean Celebration Lobster, Crab & Shrimp Flavor Soft & Crunchy Cat Treats, 5.29-oz bag
Temptations ShakeUps Crustacean Celebration Lobster, Crab & Shrimp Flavor Soft & Crunchy Cat Treats, 5.29-oz bag
Temptations ShakeUps Crustacean Celebration Lobster, Crab & Shrimp Flavor Soft & Crunchy Cat Treats, 5.29-oz bag
Temptations ShakeUps Crustacean Celebration Lobster, Crab & Shrimp Flavor Soft & Crunchy Cat Treats, 5.29-oz bag

Temptations ShakeUps Crustacean Celebration Lobster, Crab & Shrimp Flavor Soft & Crunchy Cat Treats, 5.29-oz bag

Rated 4.8 out of 5 stars
3,630
$3.99 Chewy Price
($0.76/oz)
Promo, New Customers Only: Spend $49+, get $20 off

Our ratings

Flavor options

4.7/5
Excellent

Nutritional value

4.7/5
Excellent

Palatability

4.6/5
Excellent

Texture

4.7/5
Excellent

Is this temptations cat treat right for my pet?

Lifestage

All Lifestages, Adult

Top Ingredients

Chicken By-Product Meal, Ground Corn, Animal Fat (Preserved With Mixed Tocopherols), Wheat Flour, Brewers Rice

Food Flavor

Shrimp, Seafood & Fish

Packaging Type

Bag
5
Temptations Indoor Care Chicken Flavor Soft & Crunchy Cat Treats, 4.9-oz bag
Temptations Indoor Care Chicken Flavor Soft & Crunchy Cat Treats, 4.9-oz bag
Temptations Indoor Care Chicken Flavor Soft & Crunchy Cat Treats, 4.9-oz bag
Temptations Indoor Care Chicken Flavor Soft & Crunchy Cat Treats, 4.9-oz bag
Temptations Indoor Care Chicken Flavor Soft & Crunchy Cat Treats, 4.9-oz bag
Temptations Indoor Care Chicken Flavor Soft & Crunchy Cat Treats, 4.9-oz bag
Temptations Indoor Care Chicken Flavor Soft & Crunchy Cat Treats, 4.9-oz bag
Temptations Indoor Care Chicken Flavor Soft & Crunchy Cat Treats, 4.9-oz bag
Temptations Indoor Care Chicken Flavor Soft & Crunchy Cat Treats, 4.9-oz bag

Temptations Indoor Care Chicken Flavor Soft & Crunchy Cat Treats, 4.9-oz bag

Rated 4.8 out of 5 stars
5,326
$3.98 Chewy Price
($0.82/oz)
Promo, New Customers Only: Spend $49+, get $20 off

Our ratings

Flavor options

4.7/5
Excellent

Nutritional value

4.6/5
Excellent

Palatability

4.5/5
Great

Texture

4.6/5
Excellent

Is this temptations cat treat right for my pet?

Lifestage

All Lifestages, Adult

Top Ingredients

Chicken By-Product Meal, Animal Fat (Preserved With Mixed Tocopherols), Ground Corn, Wheat Flour, Brewers Rice

Special Diet

Indoor

Food Flavor

Chicken, Poultry
6
Temptations Chicken & Dairy Flavor Crunchy & Soft Kitten Treats, 6.3-oz bag
Temptations Chicken & Dairy Flavor Crunchy & Soft Kitten Treats, 6.3-oz bag
Temptations Chicken & Dairy Flavor Crunchy & Soft Kitten Treats, 6.3-oz bag
Temptations Chicken & Dairy Flavor Crunchy & Soft Kitten Treats, 6.3-oz bag
Temptations Chicken & Dairy Flavor Crunchy & Soft Kitten Treats, 6.3-oz bag
Temptations Chicken & Dairy Flavor Crunchy & Soft Kitten Treats, 6.3-oz bag
Temptations Chicken & Dairy Flavor Crunchy & Soft Kitten Treats, 6.3-oz bag
Temptations Chicken & Dairy Flavor Crunchy & Soft Kitten Treats, 6.3-oz bag
Temptations Chicken & Dairy Flavor Crunchy & Soft Kitten Treats, 6.3-oz bag

Temptations Chicken & Dairy Flavor Crunchy & Soft Kitten Treats, 6.3-oz bag

Rated 4.8 out of 5 stars
2,221
$3.98 Chewy Price
($0.64/oz)
Promo, New Customers Only: Spend $49+, get $20 off

Our ratings

Flavor options

4.7/5
Excellent

Nutritional value

4.7/5
Excellent

Palatability

4.5/5
Great

Texture

4.6/5
Excellent

Is this temptations cat treat right for my pet?

Lifestage

Kitten

Top Ingredients

Chicken By-Product Meal, Ground Corn, Animal Fat (Preserved With Mixed Tocopherols), Wheat Flour, Brewers Rice

Food Flavor

Chicken

Packaging Type

Bag
7
Temptations Jumbo Stuff Tempting Tuna Flavor Soft & Crunchy Cat Treats, 14-oz tub
Temptations Jumbo Stuff Tempting Tuna Flavor Soft & Crunchy Cat Treats, 14-oz tub
Temptations Jumbo Stuff Tempting Tuna Flavor Soft & Crunchy Cat Treats, 14-oz tub
Temptations Jumbo Stuff Tempting Tuna Flavor Soft & Crunchy Cat Treats, 14-oz tub
Temptations Jumbo Stuff Tempting Tuna Flavor Soft & Crunchy Cat Treats, 14-oz tub
Temptations Jumbo Stuff Tempting Tuna Flavor Soft & Crunchy Cat Treats, 14-oz tub
Temptations Jumbo Stuff Tempting Tuna Flavor Soft & Crunchy Cat Treats, 14-oz tub
Temptations Jumbo Stuff Tempting Tuna Flavor Soft & Crunchy Cat Treats, 14-oz tub
Temptations Jumbo Stuff Tempting Tuna Flavor Soft & Crunchy Cat Treats, 14-oz tub

Temptations Jumbo Stuff Tempting Tuna Flavor Soft & Crunchy Cat Treats, 14-oz tub

Rated 4.7 out of 5 stars
2,777
$8.48 Chewy Price
($0.61/oz)
Promo, New Customers Only: Spend $49+, get $20 off

Our ratings

Flavor options

4.6/5
Excellent

Nutritional value

4.4/5
Great

Palatability

4.3/5
Great

Texture

4.4/5
Great

Is this temptations cat treat right for my pet?

Lifestage

All Lifestages, Adult

Top Ingredients

Chicken By-Product Meal, Ground Corn, Animal Fat (Preserved With Mixed Tocopherols), Wheat Flour, Brewers Rice

Food Flavor

Tuna, Seafood & Fish

Packaging Type

Tub
8
Temptations Wacky Blasts Cluckin’ Bacon Flavor Crunchy Cat Treats, 16-oz tub
Temptations Wacky Blasts Cluckin’ Bacon Flavor Crunchy Cat Treats, 16-oz tub
Temptations Wacky Blasts Cluckin’ Bacon Flavor Crunchy Cat Treats, 16-oz tub
Temptations Wacky Blasts Cluckin’ Bacon Flavor Crunchy Cat Treats, 16-oz tub
Temptations Wacky Blasts Cluckin’ Bacon Flavor Crunchy Cat Treats, 16-oz tub
Temptations Wacky Blasts Cluckin’ Bacon Flavor Crunchy Cat Treats, 16-oz tub
Temptations Wacky Blasts Cluckin’ Bacon Flavor Crunchy Cat Treats, 16-oz tub
Temptations Wacky Blasts Cluckin’ Bacon Flavor Crunchy Cat Treats, 16-oz tub
Temptations Wacky Blasts Cluckin’ Bacon Flavor Crunchy Cat Treats, 16-oz tub

Temptations Wacky Blasts Cluckin’ Bacon Flavor Crunchy Cat Treats, 16-oz tub

Rated 4.5 out of 5 stars
378
$8.53 Chewy Price
($0.54/oz)
Promo, New Customers Only: Spend $49+, get $20 off

Our ratings

Flavor options

4.6/5
Excellent

Nutritional value

4.3/5
Great

Palatability

4.0/5
Great

Texture

4.2/5
Great

Is this temptations cat treat right for my pet?

Lifestage

Adult

Top Ingredients

Chicken By-Product Meal, Ground Corn, Animal Fat (Preserved With Mixed Tocopherols), Wheat Flour, Brewers Rice

Food Flavor

Poultry, Meat, Cheese, Chicken...

Packaging Type

Tub
9
Temptations Classics & MixUps Mega Variety Pack Crunchy & Soft Cat Treats, 6.3-oz bag, case of 4
Temptations Classics & MixUps Mega Variety Pack Crunchy & Soft Cat Treats, 6.3-oz bag, case of 4
Temptations Classics & MixUps Mega Variety Pack Crunchy & Soft Cat Treats, 6.3-oz bag, case of 4
Temptations Classics & MixUps Mega Variety Pack Crunchy & Soft Cat Treats, 6.3-oz bag, case of 4
Temptations Classics & MixUps Mega Variety Pack Crunchy & Soft Cat Treats, 6.3-oz bag, case of 4
Temptations Classics & MixUps Mega Variety Pack Crunchy & Soft Cat Treats, 6.3-oz bag, case of 4

Temptations Classics & MixUps Mega Variety Pack Crunchy & Soft Cat Treats, 6.3-oz bag, case of 4

Rated 4.8 out of 5 stars
274
$16.91 Chewy Price
($0.68/oz)
Promo, New Customers Only: Spend $49+, get $20 off

Our ratings

Flavor options

4.7/5
Excellent

Nutritional value

4.6/5
Excellent

Palatability

4.8/5
Excellent

Texture

4.8/5
Excellent

Is this temptations cat treat right for my pet?

Lifestage

All Lifestages, Adult

Top Ingredients

Creamy Dairy: Chicken By-Product Meal, Ground Corn, Animal Fat (preserved with Mixed Tocopherols), Brewers Rice, Wheat Flour

Food Flavor

Cheese, Shrimp, Salmon, Seafood & Fish...

Packaging Type

Bag
10
Temptations Tender Fills Grilled Salmon Flavor Soft & Crunchy Cat Treats, 4.6-oz pouch
Temptations Tender Fills Grilled Salmon Flavor Soft & Crunchy Cat Treats, 4.6-oz pouch
Temptations Tender Fills Grilled Salmon Flavor Soft & Crunchy Cat Treats, 4.6-oz pouch
Temptations Tender Fills Grilled Salmon Flavor Soft & Crunchy Cat Treats, 4.6-oz pouch
Temptations Tender Fills Grilled Salmon Flavor Soft & Crunchy Cat Treats, 4.6-oz pouch
Temptations Tender Fills Grilled Salmon Flavor Soft & Crunchy Cat Treats, 4.6-oz pouch
Temptations Tender Fills Grilled Salmon Flavor Soft & Crunchy Cat Treats, 4.6-oz pouch
Temptations Tender Fills Grilled Salmon Flavor Soft & Crunchy Cat Treats, 4.6-oz pouch
Temptations Tender Fills Grilled Salmon Flavor Soft & Crunchy Cat Treats, 4.6-oz pouch

Temptations Tender Fills Grilled Salmon Flavor Soft & Crunchy Cat Treats, 4.6-oz pouch

Rated 4.3 out of 5 stars
632
$3.98 Chewy Price
($0.87/oz)
Promo, New Customers Only: Spend $49+, get $20 off

Our ratings

Flavor options

4.2/5
Great

Nutritional value

4.1/5
Great

Palatability

4.0/5
Great

Texture

4.1/5
Great

Is this temptations cat treat right for my pet?

Lifestage

All Lifestages, Adult

Top Ingredients

Animal Fat (Preserved With Mixed Tocopherols), Wheat Gluten, Wheat Flour, Corn Flour, Soy Flour

Food Flavor

Salmon, Seafood & Fish

Packaging Type

Pouch