1. Home
  2. Dog
  3. Food & Nutrition

Halloween Dog Treat Recipe: This Witch’s Potion Punch Is a Slurp-Worthy Treat

BeChewy Editors
By BeChewy Editors
Updated
Apr. 30, 2025
halloween dog treat recipe: witch's potion punch

Photo by Chewy Studios

Made with fresh, good-for-pups foods, like bananas and peas and cucumbers, this five-ingredient recipe is a tasty Halloween dog treat your dog (and their costume-wearing crew!) will happily slurp up. Here’s how to make a green-hued dog-friendly punch that all the canine guests at your Halloween party this year will love.

As with any human food, pet parents looking to incorporate new foods in their dog’s diet should consult with their veterinarian beforehand.

Witch's Potion Punch


Yield:
About 3 cups

Serving size:
1 cup

Prep time:
10 minutes

Total time:
10 minutes

Ingredients

1/2 cup low-sodium chicken broth

1/2 cup frozen banana, sliced

1/2 of a fresh cucumber (about 3/4 cup), washed well and roughly chopped, but not peeled

1/2 cup frozen peas, thawed

2 tablespoons all-natural creamy peanut butter*
*Make sure your peanut butter does not contain xylitol, which is toxic to dogs.

Supplies

Blender

Measuring cup

Measuring spoon

Optional: A cauldron-like bowl for serving

Instructions

1. Add all ingredients to blender.

Image

2. Cover with lid and blend until you have a smoothie consistency.

Image

3. Pour out about 1 cup’s worth for your pup into a bowl and serve.

You can store the rest in the fridge in an airtight container for up to 3 days. To really set the magical mood, pour into food-safe, cauldron-like bowl to serve.
Image

How Much To Serve Your Dog


As you would with any other treat, serve your pooch a small amount. Treats should only constitute a small percentage of your pet’s daily dog food. We’re talking no more than 10 percent of your pet’s diet (and if your pet is overweight, even less than that).

For example, if your pet needs 600 calories per day, they should have no more than 60 calories from treats. Feeding too many treats can lead to nutrient deficiencies.

Our Favorite Store-bought Halloween Dog Treats


Recommended Products

Blue Buffalo Boo Bars Pumpkin & Cinnamon Crunchy Dog Treats, 11-oz bag
Out of Stock
Blue Buffalo Boo Bars Pumpkin & Cinnamon Crunchy Dog Treats, 11-oz bag
Rated 4.6 out of 5 stars
4.6
963Reviews
$4.48Chewy Price
View Item Details
Zuke's Mini Naturals Pumpkins Turkey & Pumpkin Recipe Dog Treats, 5-oz bag
Out of Stock
Zuke's Mini Naturals Pumpkins Turkey & Pumpkin Recipe Dog Treats, 5-oz bag
Rated 4.6 out of 5 stars
4.6
863Reviews
$7.99Chewy Price
View Item Details
Milk-Bone Maro Snacks Halloween Dog Treats, 25-oz can
Out of Stock
Milk-Bone Maro Snacks Halloween Dog Treats, 25-oz can
Rated 4.6 out of 5 stars
4.6
296Reviews
$6.99Chewy Price
View Item Details
The Lazy Dog Cookie Co. Spooktacular Snacks Honeyed Apple & Cinnamon Dog Treats, 5-oz bag
The Lazy Dog Cookie Co. Spooktacular Snacks Honeyed Apple & Cinnamon Dog Treats, 5-oz bag
Rated 4.5 out of 5 stars
4.5
128Reviews
$6.49Chewy Price
Photo of a dog and cat in costume with text reading "Get in the spirit. Save on spooky faves to get the party started. Shop now"
Have a safe and fun Halloween! Here are more ways to make this Halloween a memorable one for you and your pets this year.

Attributions


This recipe was reviewed by a veterinarian. It is intended as a treat or snack. Treats should only constitute a small percentage of your dog’s daily food. Feeding too many treats can lead to nutrient deficiencies. If your pet has health issues (including sensitivities to fats) or if you have any concerns, consult your pet’s veterinarian before offering these food items.


BeChewy Editors

BeChewy Editors

Related articles
  • Can Dogs Eat Turkey?
    Can Dogs Eat Turkey?

  • Can Dogs Eat Dandelions?
    Can Dogs Eat Dandelions?

  • Can Dogs Have Cinnamon? Is Cinnamon Toxic to Dogs?
    Can Dogs Have Cinnamon? Is Cinnamon Toxic to Dogs?

  • Can Dogs Eat Eggs?
    Can Dogs Eat Eggs?
Skip to searchSkip to main content
Not in the U.S?

Not shopping in the U.S. or plan on shipping to a Canadian address?

Continue to Canada site
Use App
24/7 HelpHelp
Get help from our experts 24/7
1-800-672-4399
    • Track Order
    • -
    • FAQs
    • -
    • Contact Info
    AccountAccount
    Sign InNew Customer? Start here
    • Account
    • Orders
    • Manage Autoship
    • Favorites
    • Buy Again
    • Prescriptions
    • Pet Portal
    • Connect with a Vet
    • Pet Insurance Dashboard
    • My Rescues
    • Create a Pet Profile
    CartCart
    Your cart is empty.
    Something missing? Sign in to see items you may have added from another computer or device.
    Not in the U.S?

    Not shopping in the U.S. or plan on shipping to a Canadian address?

    Continue to Canada site
    Use App
    24/7 Help
    Get help from our experts 24/7
    1-800-672-4399
      • Track Order
      • -
      • FAQs
      • -
      • Contact Info
      AccountAccount
      Sign InNew Customer? Start here
      • Account
      • Orders
      • Manage Autoship
      • Favorites
      • Buy Again
      • Prescriptions
      • Pet Portal
      • Connect with a Vet
      • Pet Insurance Dashboard
      • My Rescues
      • Create a Pet Profile
      CartCart
      Your cart is empty.
      Something missing? Sign in to see items you may have added from another computer or device.
      Food
      • Dry Food
      • Wet Food
      • Fresh Food & Toppers
      • Veterinary Diets
      • Shop by Health Condition
      • Puppy Food
      Treats
      • Bones, Bully Sticks & Naturals
      • Soft & Chewy Treats
      • Dental Treats
      • Biscuits & Cookies
      • Long-Lasting Chews
      • Jerky Treats
      • Freeze-Dried & Dehydrated
      Toys
      • Plush Toys
      • Chew Toys
      • Fetch Toys
      • Treat Dispensing Toys
      • Puzzle Toys
      • Rope & Tug Toys
      Supplies
      • Crates, Pens & Gates
      • Beds
      • Leashes, Collars & Harnesses
      • Bowls & Feeders
      • Clothing & Accessories
      • Carriers & Travel
      • Training & Behavior
      Dog DealsNew Dog SuppliesPet Parent SuppliesShop all Dog
      Grooming
      • Brushes & Combs
      • Shampoos & Conditioners
      • Grooming Tools
      • Paw & Nail Care
      • Ear Care
      • Skin Care
      Cleaning & Potty
      • Pee Pads & Diapers
      • Poop Bags & Scoopers
      • Cleaners & Stain Removers
      • Vacuums & Steam Cleaners
      Health & Pharmacy
      • Flea & Tick
      • Anxiety & Calming Care
      • Allergy & Itch Relief
      • Vitamins & Supplements
      • Heartworm & Dewormers
      • Pharmacy & Prescriptions
      • DNA Testing Kits
      Gift Cards
      Popular Brands
      Purina Pro Plan
      Hill's
      Blue Buffalo
      Frisco
      Royal Canin
      Bark
      Elevate your puppy's diet. Get adventure-ready with ORIJEN puppy. Shop now.
      Food
      • Wet Food
      • Dry Food
      • Everyday Favorites
      • Shop by Health Consideration
      • Veterinary Diets
      • Highest Quality Food
      • Food Toppers
      Litter
      • Clumping
      • Scented
      • Unscented
      • Natural
      • Lightweight
      Treats
      • Crunchy Treats
      • Lickable Treats
      • Soft & Chewy Treats
      • Dental Treats
      • Catnip & Cat Grass
      Toys
      • Interactive & Electronic Toys
      • Teasers & Wands
      • Balls & Chasers
      • Catnip Toys
      • Plush & Mice Toys
      Cat DealsPet Parent SuppliesShop all Cat
      Supplies
      • Litter Boxes & Accessories
      • Cat Tech & Smart Home
      • Beds
      • Carriers & Travel
      • Bowls & Feeders
      • Collars, Leashes & Harnesses
      • Grooming
      Trees & Scratchers
      • Trees & Condos
      • Scratchers & Scratching Posts
      • Wall Shelves
      • Window Perches
      Health & Pharmacy
      • Flea & Tick
      • Anxiety & Calming Care
      • Allergy & Itch Relief
      • Vitamins & Supplements
      • Urinary Tract & Kidneys
      • Pharmacy & Prescriptions
      • Test Kits
      Gift Cards
      Popular Brands
      Tiny Tiger
      Shop Blue Buffalo
      Shop litter robot
      Shop Temptations
      Shop Hill's Science Diet
      Shop Purina Pro Plan
      Help support their urinary health with Royal Canin Urinary nutrition. Shop now.
      Horse
      • Feed
      • Treats
      • Health & Wellness
      • Vitamins & Supplements
      • Fly Control
      • Prescription Medications
      • Vaccines
      Chicken
      • Feed
      • Treats
      • Nesting & Egg Supplies
      • Coops & Runs
      • Feeders, Waterers & Deicers
      Farm Animal
      • Cattle
      • Goat
      • Pig
      • Sheep
      • Llama & Alpaca
      Wild Bird & Wildlife
      • Wild Bird
      • Squirrel & Critter
      • Duck & Waterfowl
      • Deer
      Small Pet
      • Rabbit
      • Guinea Pig
      • Hamster
      • Ferret
      Pet Bird
      • Food
      • Treats
      • Toys & Perches
      • Litter & Nesting
      • Cages & Accessories
      Fish
      • Tanks & Aquariums
      • Food
      • Filters & Media
      • Decor & Substrate
      • Water Care
      Reptile & Amphibian
      • Live Feed
      • Food & Treats
      • Tanks & Terrariums
      • Heating & Lighting
      • Substrate & Bedding
      Gift Cards
      Popular Brands
      Shop Buckeye
      Shop Animed
      Shop Cosequin
      Chewy Chick Days deals. Save on feed & supplies for every life stage. Shop now.
      Prescriptions
      Order your pet's prescription items.
      How it works
      Shop all Pharmacy
      Health Services
      Chewy Vet Care
      Chat free with our vet team
      CarePlus Insurance & Wellness Plans
      Compounded Medications
      Choose from a variety of flavors, strengths, and forms for your pet or horse.
      Learn about compounding
      Dog
      • Flea & Tick
      • Heartworm
      • Pain Relief & Arthritis
      • Antibiotics
      • Allergy Relief
      • Anxiety & Calming
      • Ear & Eye Care
      • Diabetes Care & Insulin
      Cat
      • Flea & Tick
      • Dewormers & Parasiticides
      • Ear & Eye Care
      • Antibiotics
      • Allergy Relief
      • Urinary Tract & Kidneys
      • Pain Relief & Arthritis
      • Diabetes Care & Insulin
      Horse
      • Anti-inflammatory & Musculoskeletal
      • Vitamins & Electrolytes
      • Skin & Coat Care
      • Antibiotics
      • Metabolic & Endocrine
      • Allergy & Immune
      • Behavioral Support & Sedatives
      • Reproductive Care
      Expert Health Tips
      • PetMD
      Connect with a Vet
      Free chat or live-video advice from our licensed veterinary team.
      Learn more
      CarePlus Insurance & Wellness Plans
      Give your pet the best possible health coverage with wellness and insurance plans.
      Learn more
      Chewy Vet Care
      Exceptional in-person routine and urgent care from our compassionate veterinary teams.
      Schedule a visit
      Learn
      How We Give Back
      We've donated more than $100M in products to rescue animal centers.
      Learn more
      Donate to a Rescue
      You can help us make an impact by donating items to your local shelter.
      Find a Rescue
      Find Pets to Adopt
      Search thousands of pets from shelters and rescues in Chewy's network.
      Find Pets
      Join Our Network
      Join our network to access benefits and resources that’ll help more pets.
      Join Now
      Today's Deals
      • Our experts are available 24/7:We're here 24/7:
      • 1-800-672-4399
      • United States
      • About
      • Investor Relations
      • Affiliates
      • Jobs
      • FAQs
      • Learn
      • Give Back
      • Gift Cards
      • Sell on Chewy
      Download iOS appDownload Android app
      Go to ACHC pharmacy accreditationLegitscript ApprovedCompounding Pharmacy Approved
      • Copyright © 2025, Chewy, Inc.
      • Terms of Use
      • Privacy Policy (Updated Oct 8, 2024)
      • Interest-Based Ads
      • Accessibility
      • California Supply Chains Act
      • Vendor Compliance
      Download phone image
      Get the Chewy app
      Download iOS appDownload Android app
      We're here 24/7
      1-800-672-4399
      United States
      Copyright © 2025 Chewy, Inc.
      Terms-Privacy (Updated Oct 8, 2024)-Accessibility
      California Supply Chains Act-Vendor Compliance
      About-Investor Relations-Jobs-Learn
      Give Back-Gift Cards-Sell on Chewy