I got these for my cats because my roommates pug responds very well to the dog version. When I’m gone for my 12 hour shifts or overnight my cat tends to get destructive, i think separation anxiety. One of these will knock him out and his amount of eating flowers and knocking things off the counters overnight has decreased immensely. It’s not perfect but it has helped a ton. Yes, the treats are hard not soft, but he LOVES them. Even my other picky cat likes them. You could break it up into their food too. Highly recommend giving it a shot.
My 3 year old rescue did not like the flavor of this supplement. She would just smell and walk away.
The chews were hard, not soft. Tried to feed to several of my cats and not one would eat them. I haven't checked the date to see if they were getting old.