• New Pet
  • Cat
  • Toys

Toys for New Cats

(1 - 36 of 295 results)

Plush & Mice Toys Chasers & Teasers Scratchers Interactive Toys Catnip Toys
Frisco Colorful Springs Cat Toy, 10-Pack

Frisco Colorful Springs Cat Toy, 10-Pack

$3.31 Autoship & Save

$3.48

730

FREE 1-3 day shipping over $49

USD
Frisco Colorful Springs Cat Toy, 10-Pack
161807
Frisco
329
3.48
1
10-Pack
false
{ "deal": false, "strike": false, "greenbar": false }
Frisco Bird Teaser with Feathers Cat Toy, Blue More Choices Available

Frisco Bird Teaser with Feathers Cat Toy, Blue

$2.83 Autoship & Save

$2.98

981

FREE 1-3 day shipping over $49

USD
Frisco Bird Teaser with Feathers Cat Toy, Blue
161199
Frisco
1421
2.98
2
Blue
false
{ "deal": false, "strike": false, "greenbar": false }
Frisco Basic Plush Mice Cat Toy with Catnip, 3 count More Choices Available

Frisco Basic Plush Mice Cat Toy with Catnip, 3 count

$2.83 Autoship & Save

$2.98

506

FREE 1-3 day shipping over $49

USD
Frisco Basic Plush Mice Cat Toy with Catnip, 3 count
161262
Frisco
328
2.98
3
3 count
false
{ "deal": false, "strike": false, "greenbar": false }
Frisco Cat Tracks Butterfly Cat Toy

Frisco Cat Tracks Butterfly Cat Toy

$9.48 Autoship & Save

$9.98

1568

FREE 1-3 day shipping over $49

USD
Frisco Cat Tracks Butterfly Cat Toy
161805
Frisco
329
9.98
4
false
{ "deal": false, "strike": false, "greenbar": false }
Frisco Refillable Catnip Cat Toy, Brown Squirrel

Frisco Refillable Catnip Cat Toy, Brown Squirrel

$4.73 Autoship & Save

$4.98

381

FREE 1-3 day shipping over $49

USD
Frisco Refillable Catnip Cat Toy, Brown Squirrel
161271
Frisco
328
4.98
5
Brown Squirrel
false
{ "deal": false, "strike": false, "greenbar": false }
Frisco Fabric Teaser Cat Toy, Neon Bubbles More Choices Available

Frisco Fabric Teaser Cat Toy, Neon Bubbles

$3.98 $4.50

261

FREE 1-3 day shipping over $49

USD
Frisco Fabric Teaser Cat Toy, Neon Bubbles
161196
Frisco
1421
3.98
6
Neon Bubbles
false
{ "deal": false, "strike": false, "greenbar": false }
All Kind Double Cat Scratcher Toy Refill with Catnip, 2-Pack

All Kind Double Cat Scratcher Toy Refill with Catnip, 2-Pack

$4.73 Autoship & Save

$4.98

154

FREE 1-3 day shipping over $49

USD
All Kind Double Cat Scratcher Toy Refill with Catnip, 2-Pack
174800
All Kind
393
4.98
7
false
{ "deal": false, "strike": false, "greenbar": false }
All Kind Step-In Cat Scratcher Toy with Catnip, Tropical Palms
Deal

All Kind Step-In Cat Scratcher Toy with Catnip, Tropical Palms

$10.43 Autoship & Save

$10.98

394

FREE 1-3 day shipping over $49

USD
All Kind Step-In Cat Scratcher Toy with Catnip, Tropical Palms
174793
All Kind
393
10.98
8
false
{ "deal": true, "strike": false, "greenbar": false }
Petstages Tower of Tracks Cat Toy

Petstages Tower of Tracks Cat Toy

$10.44 Autoship & Save

$10.99 $24.99

3962

FREE 1-3 day shipping over $49

USD
Petstages Tower of Tracks Cat Toy
98978
Petstages
329
10.99
9
10-in
false
{ "deal": false, "strike": false, "greenbar": false }
All Kind Double Cat Scratcher Toy with Catnip, Tropical Palms More Choices Available

All Kind Double Cat Scratcher Toy with Catnip, Tropical Palms

$6.63 Autoship & Save

$6.98

266

FREE 1-3 day shipping over $49

USD
All Kind Double Cat Scratcher Toy with Catnip, Tropical Palms
174798
All Kind
393
6.98
10
Tropical Palms
false
{ "deal": false, "strike": false, "greenbar": false }
SmartyKat Hot Pursuit Electronic Concealed Motion Cat Toy, Blue

SmartyKat Hot Pursuit Electronic Concealed Motion Cat Toy, Blue

$11.96 $29.99

2023

FREE 1-3 day shipping over $49

USD
SmartyKat Hot Pursuit Electronic Concealed Motion Cat Toy, Blue
132636
SmartyKat
2258
11.96
11
Blue
false
{ "deal": false, "strike": false, "greenbar": false }
Frisco Sushi Plush Cat Toy with Catnip, 4-count

Frisco Sushi Plush Cat Toy with Catnip, 4-count

$6.98

107

FREE 1-3 day shipping over $49

USD
Frisco Sushi Plush Cat Toy with Catnip, 4-count
213910
Frisco
328
6.98
12
false
{ "deal": false, "strike": false, "greenbar": false }
Pet Zone Play-N-Squeak MouseHunter Cat Toy with Catnip

Pet Zone Play-N-Squeak MouseHunter Cat Toy with Catnip

$6.29

715

FREE 1-3 day shipping over $49

USD
Pet Zone Play-N-Squeak MouseHunter Cat Toy with Catnip
55741
Pet Zone
328
6.29
13
false
{ "deal": false, "strike": false, "greenbar": false }
Frisco Sparkle Fish Cat Toy with Catnip, 2-Pack

Frisco Sparkle Fish Cat Toy with Catnip, 2-Pack

$4.98

49

FREE 1-3 day shipping over $49

USD
Frisco Sparkle Fish Cat Toy with Catnip, 2-Pack
166361
Frisco
329
4.98
14
false
{ "deal": false, "strike": false, "greenbar": false }
Frisco Peek-a-Boo Cat Chute Cat Toy, Colorful Tri-Tunnel

Frisco Peek-a-Boo Cat Chute Cat Toy, Colorful Tri-Tunnel

$12.33 Autoship & Save

$12.98 $13.98

361

FREE 1-3 day shipping over $49

USD
Frisco Peek-a-Boo Cat Chute Cat Toy, Colorful Tri-Tunnel
166382
Frisco
329
12.98
15
false
{ "deal": false, "strike": false, "greenbar": false }
All Kind Paw & Play Mouse Cat Toy, 10-Pack

All Kind Paw & Play Mouse Cat Toy, 10-Pack

$4.98

108

FREE 1-3 day shipping over $49

USD
All Kind Paw & Play Mouse Cat Toy, 10-Pack
166366
All Kind
328
4.98
16
false
{ "deal": false, "strike": false, "greenbar": false }
Frisco Bouncy Mouse Cat Toy, Blue More Choices Available

Frisco Bouncy Mouse Cat Toy, Blue

$3.78 Autoship & Save

$3.98

231

FREE 1-3 day shipping over $49

USD
Frisco Bouncy Mouse Cat Toy, Blue
161259
Frisco
1421
3.98
17
Blue
false
{ "deal": false, "strike": false, "greenbar": false }
Frisco Plush, Teaser, Ball & Tri-Tunnel Variety Pack Cat Toy with Catnip, 20-count

Frisco Plush, Teaser, Ball & Tri-Tunnel Variety Pack Cat Toy with Catnip, 20-count

$19.98

221

FREE 1-3 day shipping over $49

USD
Frisco Plush, Teaser, Ball & Tri-Tunnel Variety Pack Cat Toy with Catnip, 20-count
178161
Frisco
329
19.98
18
false
{ "deal": false, "strike": false, "greenbar": false }
SunGrow Mylar Crinkle Ball Kitten Toy, 12 count
Deal

SunGrow Mylar Crinkle Ball Kitten Toy, 12 count

$6.49 $9.20

54

FREE 1-3 day shipping over $49

USD
SunGrow Mylar Crinkle Ball Kitten Toy, 12 count
215394
SunGrow
329
6.49
19
12 count,2-in
false
{ "deal": true, "strike": false, "greenbar": false }
Frisco Plush Kicker Cat Toy, Orange Fox More Choices Available

Frisco Plush Kicker Cat Toy, Orange Fox

$4.98

397

FREE 1-3 day shipping over $49

USD
Frisco Plush Kicker Cat Toy, Orange Fox
161264
Frisco
328
4.98
20
Orange Fox
false
{ "deal": false, "strike": false, "greenbar": false }
Pet Fit For Life 5 Piece Squiggly Worm Wand Cat Toy

Pet Fit For Life 5 Piece Squiggly Worm Wand Cat Toy

$9.95

924

FREE 1-3 day shipping over $49

USD
Pet Fit For Life 5 Piece Squiggly Worm Wand Cat Toy
140078
Pet Fit For Life
1421
9.95
21
false
{ "deal": false, "strike": false, "greenbar": false }
Frisco Skinny Mouse Catnip Cat Toy, Gray More Choices Available

Frisco Skinny Mouse Catnip Cat Toy, Gray

$3.48

167

FREE 1-3 day shipping over $49

USD
Frisco Skinny Mouse Catnip Cat Toy, Gray
161269
Frisco
328
3.48
22
Gray
false
{ "deal": false, "strike": false, "greenbar": false }
OurPets Catnip 24 Karat Cat Toy

OurPets Catnip 24 Karat Cat Toy

$3.95

629

FREE 1-3 day shipping over $49

USD
OurPets Catnip 24 Karat Cat Toy
55678
OurPets
328
3.95
23
false
{ "deal": false, "strike": false, "greenbar": false }
Frisco 47-in Foldable Crinkle Play Tunnel with 2 Windows

Frisco 47-in Foldable Crinkle Play Tunnel with 2 Windows

$14.23 Autoship & Save

$14.98

562

FREE 1-3 day shipping over $49

USD
Frisco 47-in Foldable Crinkle Play Tunnel with 2 Windows
140168
Frisco
2258
14.98
24
false
{ "deal": false, "strike": false, "greenbar": false }
Frisco Mythical Mates Dragon Crinkle Cat Toy with Catnip

Frisco Mythical Mates Dragon Crinkle Cat Toy with Catnip

$3.98

40

FREE 1-3 day shipping over $49

USD
Frisco Mythical Mates Dragon Crinkle Cat Toy with Catnip
204527
Frisco
328
3.98
25
false
{ "deal": false, "strike": false, "greenbar": false }
Pet Fit For Life 6 Piece Replacement Feather Pack for Wand Cat Toy

Pet Fit For Life 6 Piece Replacement Feather Pack for Wand Cat Toy

$10.95

175

FREE 1-3 day shipping over $49

USD
Pet Fit For Life 6 Piece Replacement Feather Pack for Wand Cat Toy
109318
Pet Fit For Life
1421
10.95
26
false
{ "deal": false, "strike": false, "greenbar": false }
Petstages Magic Dynamite Cat Toy with Catnip

Petstages Magic Dynamite Cat Toy with Catnip

$5.11 $7.99

222

FREE 1-3 day shipping over $49

USD
Petstages Magic Dynamite Cat Toy with Catnip
64657
Petstages
329
5.11
27
false
{ "deal": false, "strike": false, "greenbar": false }
All Kind Plush, Teaser, Ball & Tunnel Variety Pack Cat Toy with Catnip, 25-count

All Kind Plush, Teaser, Ball & Tunnel Variety Pack Cat Toy with Catnip, 25-count

$18.03 Autoship & Save

$18.98

271

FREE 1-3 day shipping over $49

USD
All Kind Plush, Teaser, Ball & Tunnel Variety Pack Cat Toy with Catnip, 25-count
169688
All Kind
328
18.98
28
false
{ "deal": false, "strike": false, "greenbar": false }
Frisco Plush Donut Cat Toy with Catnip, 2-Pack

Frisco Plush Donut Cat Toy with Catnip, 2-Pack

$4.98

38

FREE 1-3 day shipping over $49

USD
Frisco Plush Donut Cat Toy with Catnip, 2-Pack
213850
Frisco
328
4.98
29
false
{ "deal": false, "strike": false, "greenbar": false }
Fat Cat Big Mama's Cat Scratcher Toy with Catnip

Fat Cat Big Mama's Cat Scratcher Toy with Catnip

$9.99 $14.99

590

FREE 1-3 day shipping over $49

USD
Fat Cat Big Mama's Cat Scratcher Toy with Catnip
54941
Fat Cat
393
9.99
30
Double wide box
false
{ "deal": false, "strike": false, "greenbar": false }
SmartyKat Chickadee Chirp Electronic Bird-Sound Cat Toy

SmartyKat Chickadee Chirp Electronic Bird-Sound Cat Toy

$4.99 $6.99

636

FREE 1-3 day shipping over $49

USD
SmartyKat Chickadee Chirp Electronic Bird-Sound Cat Toy
102753
SmartyKat
329
4.99
31
false
{ "deal": false, "strike": false, "greenbar": false }
Yeowww! Catnip Yellow Banana Cat Toy

Yeowww! Catnip Yellow Banana Cat Toy

$5.99

2038

FREE 1-3 day shipping over $49

USD
Yeowww! Catnip Yellow Banana Cat Toy
102761
Yeowww!
328
5.99
32
false
{ "deal": false, "strike": false, "greenbar": false }
OurPets Hot Stuff Cat Toy

OurPets Hot Stuff Cat Toy

$3.95 $5.33

253

FREE 1-3 day shipping over $49

USD
OurPets Hot Stuff Cat Toy
55685
OurPets
328
3.95
33
false
{ "deal": false, "strike": false, "greenbar": false }
SmartyKat Loco Laser Cat Toy, Color Varies

SmartyKat Loco Laser Cat Toy, Color Varies

$4.33 $4.99

151

FREE 1-3 day shipping over $49

USD
SmartyKat Loco Laser Cat Toy, Color Varies
107597
SmartyKat
11133
4.33
34
false
{ "deal": false, "strike": false, "greenbar": false }
Frisco Easter Flowers Step-In Cat Scratcher Toy with Catnip
New

Frisco Easter Flowers Step-In Cat Scratcher Toy with Catnip

$12.98

8

FREE 1-3 day shipping over $49

USD
Frisco Easter Flowers Step-In Cat Scratcher Toy with Catnip
248057
Frisco
2368
12.98
35
false
{ "deal": false, "strike": false, "greenbar": false }
KONG Refillable Turtle Catnip Cat Toy

KONG Refillable Turtle Catnip Cat Toy

$4.06

179

FREE 1-3 day shipping over $49

USD
KONG Refillable Turtle Catnip Cat Toy
59302
KONG
328
4.06
36
false
{ "deal": false, "strike": false, "greenbar": false }
  • Prev
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • 6
  • ...
  • 9
  • Next

Filter by:

Categories

  • Plush & Mice Toys (47)
  • Chasers & Teasers (32)
  • Scratchers (42)
  • Interactive Toys (29)
  • Catnip Toys (61)

Autoship & Save Eligible

  • true (19)

Pet

  • Cat (294)
  • Dog (1)

Product Category

  • Toys (295)

Brand

  • All For Paws (5)
  • All Kind (6)
  • Armarkat (1)
  • Bergan (2)
  • Best Friends by Sheri (1)
  • Best Pet Supplies (3)
  • Cat Craft (1)
  • Cat Love (1)
  • Catit (9)
  • Chewy Exclusives (86)
  • Coastal Pet Products (2)
  • Disney (2)
  • District 70 (3)
  • Doggles (2)
  • Ethical Pet (7)
  • Fat Cat (11)
  • Feline Ruff (1)
  • Frisco (77)
  • FurHaven (1)
  • FurryFido (1)
  • FUZZU (5)
  • Go Cat (1)
  • Hagen (2)
  • Hartz (6)
  • Hauspanther (3)
  • Iconic Pet (2)
  • Imperial Cat (2)
  • Jackson Galaxy (2)
  • JW Pet (6)
  • K&H Pet Products (4)
  • KONG (22)
  • LIFE IS GOOD (1)
  • Mad Cat (13)
  • MidWest (1)
  • Multipet (2)
  • Necoichi (3)
  • OurPets (12)
  • Outward Hound (4)
  • Penn-Plax (1)
  • Pet Fit For Life (6)
  • Pet Krewe (1)
  • Pet Magasin (1)
  • Pet Zone (9)
  • PetFusion (4)
  • Petique (1)
  • Petlinks (8)
  • Petmate (9)
  • Petstages (12)
  • Pioneer Pet (1)
  • Pixar (1)
  • PURRfect (2)
  • Scratch Lounge (2)
  • SereneLife (1)
  • SmartCat (1)
  • SmartyKat (9)
  • Spot (1)
  • SunGrow (1)
  • Tiger Tough (2)
  • Trixie (1)
  • Turbo (10)
  • Ware (1)
  • Yeowww! (8)

Lifestage

  • Kitten (16)
  • Adult (274)

Material

  • Acrylic (1)
  • Aluminum (1)
  • Canvas (1)
  • Cardboard (40)
  • Cork (3)
  • Cotton (14)
  • Faux Fur (4)
  • Felt (3)
  • Fleece (4)
  • Leather (2)
  • Nylon (3)
  • Plastic (42)
  • Polyester (168)
  • Polypropylene (9)
  • Recycled Materials (7)
  • Rope (2)
  • Sisal (2)
  • Stainless Steel (1)
  • Wood (5)

Price

  • Less than $10
  • $10 to $20
  • $20 to $30
  • $30 to $40
  • $40 to $50
  • $50 & Above

Customer Rating

  • & up (293)
  • & up (294)
  • & up (295)
  • & up (295)