10 Best Cat Mice & Plush Toys 2025: According to Reviews | Chewy

The 10 Best Cat Mice & Plush Toys

Jump to the list

How we created this cat mice & plush toy list

We leveraged input from our veterinarians and artificial intelligence to identify key considerations to help you find the best cat mice & plush toy.
We scanned thousands of customer reviews and ratings and scored each product based on its performance against each of the key considerations. We then considered how popular a product is with Chewy customers and combined that with its key consideration scores to create the list of the best cat mice & plush toys.

Key cat mice & plush toy considerations

Durability

Interactive Features

Material

Size

1
Yeowww! Catnip Yellow Banana Cat Toy
Yeowww! Catnip Yellow Banana Cat Toy
Yeowww! Catnip Yellow Banana Cat Toy

Yeowww! Catnip Yellow Banana Cat Toy

Rated 4.6 out of 5 stars
9,052
$9.00Chewy Price
($9.00/ea)
Promo, Spend $100, Get $30 eGift Card with code HAVEFUN

Our ratings

Durability

4.5/5
Great

Interactive Features

4.7/5
Excellent

Material

4.5/5
Great

Size

4.4/5
Great

Is this cat mice & plush toy right for my pet?

Lifestage

All Lifestages, Adult

Material

Natural Fabric, Cotton

Toy Feature

Catnip

Toy Type

Plush Toys
2
Frisco Mice Plush Cat Toy with Catnip, 5 count
Frisco Mice Plush Cat Toy with Catnip, 5 count
Frisco Mice Plush Cat Toy with Catnip, 5 count
Frisco Mice Plush Cat Toy with Catnip, 5 count

Frisco Mice Plush Cat Toy with Catnip, 5 count

Rated 4.7 out of 5 stars
4,425
$4.99Chewy Price
($1.00/ea)
Promo, Spend $100, Get $30 eGift Card with code HAVEFUN

Our ratings

Durability

4.6/5
Excellent

Interactive Features

4.7/5
Excellent

Material

4.6/5
Excellent

Size

4.6/5
Excellent

Is this cat mice & plush toy right for my pet?

Lifestage

All Lifestages, Adult

Material

Polyester

Toy Feature

Catnip

Toy Type

Catnip, Mice Toys, Chasers
3
SmartyKat Skitter Critters Value Pack Catnip Cat Toys, 10 count
SmartyKat Skitter Critters Value Pack Catnip Cat Toys, 10 count
SmartyKat Skitter Critters Value Pack Catnip Cat Toys, 10 count
SmartyKat Skitter Critters Value Pack Catnip Cat Toys, 10 count
SmartyKat Skitter Critters Value Pack Catnip Cat Toys, 10 count
SmartyKat Skitter Critters Value Pack Catnip Cat Toys, 10 count
SmartyKat Skitter Critters Value Pack Catnip Cat Toys, 10 count
SmartyKat Skitter Critters Value Pack Catnip Cat Toys, 10 count

SmartyKat Skitter Critters Value Pack Catnip Cat Toys, 10 count

Rated 4.7 out of 5 stars
2,557
$4.97Chewy Price
($0.50/ea)
Promo, Spend $100, Get $30 eGift Card with code HAVEFUN

Our ratings

Durability

4.6/5
Excellent

Interactive Features

4.7/5
Excellent

Material

4.7/5
Excellent

Size

4.7/5
Excellent

Is this cat mice & plush toy right for my pet?

Lifestage

All Lifestages, Adult

Material

Synthetic Fabric, Polyester

Toy Feature

Catnip

Toy Type

Catnip, Mice Toys
4
Catstages Crunchy Pickle Kicker Plush Cat Toy with Catnip
Catstages Crunchy Pickle Kicker Plush Cat Toy with Catnip
Catstages Crunchy Pickle Kicker Plush Cat Toy with Catnip
Catstages Crunchy Pickle Kicker Plush Cat Toy with Catnip
Catstages Crunchy Pickle Kicker Plush Cat Toy with Catnip
Catstages Crunchy Pickle Kicker Plush Cat Toy with Catnip
Catstages Crunchy Pickle Kicker Plush Cat Toy with Catnip
Catstages Crunchy Pickle Kicker Plush Cat Toy with Catnip

Catstages Crunchy Pickle Kicker Plush Cat Toy with Catnip

Rated 4.6 out of 5 stars
3,538
$4.99Chewy Price
Promo, Spend $100, Get $30 eGift Card with code HAVEFUN

Our ratings

Durability

4.5/5
Great

Interactive Features

4.7/5
Excellent

Material

4.6/5
Excellent

Size

4.4/5
Great

Is this cat mice & plush toy right for my pet?

Lifestage

All Lifestages, Adult

Material

Synthetic Fabric, Polyester

Toy Feature

Catnip

Toy Type

Plush Toys
5
Mad Cat Big Cactus Kicker Catnip & Silvervine Cat Toy
Mad Cat Big Cactus Kicker Catnip & Silvervine Cat Toy
Mad Cat Big Cactus Kicker Catnip & Silvervine Cat Toy

Mad Cat Big Cactus Kicker Catnip & Silvervine Cat Toy

Rated 4.6 out of 5 stars
1,554
$7.99Chewy Price
Promo, Spend $100, Get $30 eGift Card with code HAVEFUN

Our ratings

Durability

4.5/5
Great

Interactive Features

4.7/5
Excellent

Material

4.6/5
Excellent

Size

4.6/5
Excellent

Is this cat mice & plush toy right for my pet?

Lifestage

All Lifestages, Adult

Material

Synthetic Fabric, Polyester

Toy Feature

Catnip

Toy Type

Plush Toys
6
KONG Refillable Turtle Catnip Cat Toy
KONG Refillable Turtle Catnip Cat Toy
KONG Refillable Turtle Catnip Cat Toy
KONG Refillable Turtle Catnip Cat Toy
KONG Refillable Turtle Catnip Cat Toy
KONG Refillable Turtle Catnip Cat Toy

KONG Refillable Turtle Catnip Cat Toy

Rated 4.5 out of 5 stars
513
$5.99Chewy Price
Promo, Spend $100, Get $30 eGift Card with code HAVEFUN

Our ratings

Durability

4.6/5
Excellent

Interactive Features

4.8/5
Excellent

Material

4.7/5
Excellent

Size

4.5/5
Great

Is this cat mice & plush toy right for my pet?

Lifestage

All Lifestages, Adult

Material

Synthetic Fabric, Polyester

Toy Feature

Exercise, Catnip

Toy Type

Plush Toys
7
Pet Zone Play-N-Squeak MouseHunter Cat Toy with Catnip
Pet Zone Play-N-Squeak MouseHunter Cat Toy with Catnip
Pet Zone Play-N-Squeak MouseHunter Cat Toy with Catnip
Pet Zone Play-N-Squeak MouseHunter Cat Toy with Catnip
Pet Zone Play-N-Squeak MouseHunter Cat Toy with Catnip
Pet Zone Play-N-Squeak MouseHunter Cat Toy with Catnip

Pet Zone Play-N-Squeak MouseHunter Cat Toy with Catnip

Rated 4.5 out of 5 stars
2,040
$5.49Chewy Price
Promo, Spend $100, Get $30 eGift Card with code HAVEFUN

Our ratings

Durability

4.4/5
Great

Interactive Features

4.6/5
Excellent

Material

4.4/5
Great

Size

4.3/5
Great

Is this cat mice & plush toy right for my pet?

Lifestage

Kitten

Material

Synthetic Fabric, Polyester

Toy Feature

Exercise, Catnip

Toy Type

Mice Toys
8
Penn-Plax Purr Pet Bag of Mice Cat Toy, Color Varies, 12 count
Penn-Plax Purr Pet Bag of Mice Cat Toy, Color Varies, 12 count
Penn-Plax Purr Pet Bag of Mice Cat Toy, Color Varies, 12 count
Penn-Plax Purr Pet Bag of Mice Cat Toy, Color Varies, 12 count
Penn-Plax Purr Pet Bag of Mice Cat Toy, Color Varies, 12 count
Penn-Plax Purr Pet Bag of Mice Cat Toy, Color Varies, 12 count
Penn-Plax Purr Pet Bag of Mice Cat Toy, Color Varies, 12 count
Penn-Plax Purr Pet Bag of Mice Cat Toy, Color Varies, 12 count

Penn-Plax Purr Pet Bag of Mice Cat Toy, Color Varies, 12 count

Rated 4.7 out of 5 stars
788
$6.87Chewy Price
($0.58/ea)
Promo, Spend $100, Get $30 eGift Card with code HAVEFUN

Our ratings

Durability

4.4/5
Great

Interactive Features

4.6/5
Excellent

Material

4.5/5
Great

Size

4.5/5
Great

Is this cat mice & plush toy right for my pet?

Lifestage

All Lifestages, Adult

Material

Synthetic Fabric, Polyester

Toy Feature

Exercise

Toy Type

Mice Toys
9
Hartz Just for Cats Toy Variety Pack, 13 count
Hartz Just for Cats Toy Variety Pack, 13 count
Hartz Just for Cats Toy Variety Pack, 13 count
Hartz Just for Cats Toy Variety Pack, 13 count
Hartz Just for Cats Toy Variety Pack, 13 count
Hartz Just for Cats Toy Variety Pack, 13 count
Hartz Just for Cats Toy Variety Pack, 13 count
Hartz Just for Cats Toy Variety Pack, 13 count

Hartz Just for Cats Toy Variety Pack, 13 count

Rated 4.6 out of 5 stars
1,075
$4.97Chewy Price
($0.39/ea)
Promo, Spend $100, Get $30 eGift Card with code HAVEFUN

Our ratings

Durability

4.5/5
Great

Interactive Features

4.7/5
Excellent

Material

4.6/5
Excellent

Size

4.5/5
Great

Is this cat mice & plush toy right for my pet?

Lifestage

All Lifestages, Adult

Material

Synthetic Fabric, Plastic, Polyester

Toy Feature

Variety Pack, Exercise, Catnip

Toy Type

Balls, Catnip, Mice Toys, Teasers & Wands...
10
Ethical Pet Spot Rainbow Plush Rattling Mice Cat Toy with Catnip, Color Varies, 12-pack
Ethical Pet Spot Rainbow Plush Rattling Mice Cat Toy with Catnip, Color Varies, 12-pack

Ethical Pet Spot Rainbow Plush Rattling Mice Cat Toy with Catnip, Color Varies, 12-pack

Rated 4.5 out of 5 stars
710
$9.54Chewy Price
($0.80/ea)
Promo, Spend $100, Get $30 eGift Card with code HAVEFUN

Our ratings

Durability

4.4/5
Great

Interactive Features

4.7/5
Excellent

Material

4.4/5
Great

Size

4.4/5
Great

Is this cat mice & plush toy right for my pet?

Lifestage

All Lifestages, Adult

Material

Synthetic Fabric, Plastic, Polyester

Toy Feature

Exercise, Catnip

Toy Type

Mice Toys